Heart failure, valves, myocardium and pericardium
The mechanisms and compensations of heart failure, the pathology of the four common valve lesions and the difference between chronic and acute, the cardiomyopathies and myocarditis, and the pericardial diseases including tamponade and constriction.
By the end of this page you should be able to
- Define heart failure and classify it by ejection fraction, by side and by time course.
- Describe the compensatory mechanisms in heart failure and explain why each eventually harms.
- Explain pressure and volume overload remodelling and apply Laplace law to it.
- Describe the pathology and consequences of aortic and mitral stenosis and regurgitation, and contrast acute with chronic.
- Classify the cardiomyopathies and describe the pathology of myocarditis.
- Explain the pathophysiology of pericarditis, pericardial effusion, tamponade and constriction.
Heart failure: definition and mechanisms
Heart failure is a clinical syndrome in which the heart cannot deliver an output adequate for tissue demands, or can only do so at the cost of raised filling pressures. It is a diagnosis about function, not about a single number.
Classify it three ways. By ejection fraction: reduced (systolic failure, a dilated poorly contracting ventricle) or preserved (diastolic failure, a stiff ventricle that fills poorly, typical of hypertension, hypertrophy, ageing, obesity and diabetes). By side: left-sided failure congests the lungs, right-sided failure congests the systemic veins and liver, and the commonest cause of right failure is left failure. By time course: chronic compensated failure, acute decompensation and acute de novo failure behave differently, because remodelling takes weeks and acute lesions allow none.
Mechanistically there are only a few ways to fail: loss of muscle (infarction), pressure overload (aortic stenosis, hypertension, pulmonary hypertension), volume overload (regurgitation, shunt, anaemia, thyrotoxicosis), impaired filling (tamponade, constriction, hypertrophy, tachyarrhythmia), arrhythmia, and direct myocyte disease (cardiomyopathy, myocarditis, toxins).
Compensation and why it fails
- Frank-Starling: dilatation raises stroke volume at first, but in a failing ventricle the curve is flat, so further filling raises pressure and causes congestion without useful gain.
- Sympathetic activation raises rate and contractility and redistributes flow, but raises oxygen demand, causes beta receptor downregulation, promotes arrhythmia and is directly toxic to myocytes.
- Renin-angiotensin-aldosterone activation restores pressure and volume, but adds afterload and preload to a failing ventricle and drives fibrosis and hypertrophy. Blocking it, and blocking sympathetic drive, improves survival; this is why the drugs that make patients feel better immediately and the drugs that keep them alive are not the same.
- Natriuretic peptides released from stretched myocardium oppose all of this and are the basis of their use as a diagnostic marker.
- Remodelling: sustained pressure overload adds sarcomeres in parallel, giving concentric hypertrophy with a thick wall and small stiff cavity; sustained volume overload adds sarcomeres in series, giving eccentric hypertrophy with a dilated cavity. By Laplace law, both initially normalise wall stress, but hypertrophied muscle outgrows its capillary supply and becomes ischaemic and fibrotic, and dilatation eventually raises wall stress and stretches the mitral annulus, producing functional regurgitation and a vicious cycle.
- Myocyte apoptosis, interstitial fibrosis, altered calcium handling and energy depletion make the process self-sustaining, so failure progresses even when the original insult has gone.
Valve lesions
- Aortic stenosis: mostly calcific degeneration of a trileaflet valve in older people, or earlier degeneration of a bicuspid valve, with rheumatic disease now less common. Pressure overload produces concentric hypertrophy with a small stiff cavity. Consequences: exertional dyspnoea, angina (demand of the thick wall with compressed intramural vessels), exertional syncope (fixed output with peripheral vasodilatation) and sudden death. The hypertrophied ventricle depends on preload and on the atrial contribution, so new atrial fibrillation, tachycardia, hypovolaemia or vasodilatation can precipitate collapse.
- Aortic regurgitation: chronic causes include aortic root dilatation, bicuspid valve and connective tissue disease; acute causes are endocarditis and aortic dissection. Chronically the ventricle dilates and hypertrophies, tolerating it for years with a wide pulse pressure and bounding pulses. Acutely there is no time to remodel, so the ventricle cannot accept the regurgitant volume, left ventricular diastolic pressure rises abruptly and pulmonary oedema with a quiet murmur and a narrow pulse pressure follows.
- Mitral stenosis: almost always rheumatic, with commissural fusion and a thickened immobile valve. The left ventricle is protected; the left atrium dilates, raising pulmonary venous and then arterial pressure. Consequences: atrial fibrillation, atrial thrombus and embolic stroke, haemoptysis, right heart failure and poor tolerance of anything that shortens diastole or removes atrial contraction.
- Mitral regurgitation: chronic from degenerative prolapse, annular dilatation in a dilated ventricle, or rheumatic disease; acute from papillary muscle or chordal rupture (classically days after an infarct) or endocarditis. Chronically the atrium and ventricle dilate and compliance protects the lungs, so symptoms are late and the ejection fraction looks falsely good. Acutely a normal-sized stiff atrium transmits pressure straight to the lungs, giving flash pulmonary oedema.
- Endocarditis is the common complication of all of them: a damaged or prosthetic valve, transient bacteraemia, adherent platelet-fibrin vegetations, destruction of the valve and of adjacent tissue, septic embolism, and immune complex phenomena.
Myocardium
- Dilated cardiomyopathy: systolic failure with four-chamber dilatation. Causes include idiopathic and genetic (cytoskeletal protein mutations), alcohol, viral, peripartum, tachycardia-related, chemotherapy (anthracyclines), haemochromatosis, thyroid disease and nutritional deficiency. Risks are arrhythmia, mural thrombus and progressive failure.
- Hypertrophic cardiomyopathy: an autosomal dominant sarcomeric protein disorder with asymmetric septal hypertrophy, myocyte disarray and fibrosis. Features are diastolic failure, dynamic outflow obstruction worsened by anything that reduces preload or afterload or increases contractility, and sudden death in young people, often on exertion.
- Restrictive and infiltrative disease: amyloid, sarcoid, haemochromatosis, radiation and endomyocardial fibrosis. The ventricles fill poorly with normal cavity size, so the picture resembles constriction.
- Stress (takotsubo) cardiomyopathy: catecholamine-mediated microvascular and myocyte dysfunction with apical ballooning, usually reversible.
- Myocarditis: mostly viral, with direct myocyte injury and then immune-mediated damage; also immune (checkpoint inhibitors), toxic and autoimmune. It presents with chest pain, failure, arrhythmia or sudden death, and troponin is raised with unobstructed coronaries. Giant cell myocarditis is a fulminant form.
Pericardium
The pericardium is a fibrous sac with a serous lining holding a small volume of fluid. It limits acute dilatation and, importantly, it is stiff when stretched quickly but compliant when stretched slowly.
Acute pericarditis is most often viral or idiopathic, and also occurs with uraemia, after infarction (early, or as the later immune Dressler syndrome), after cardiac surgery or radiotherapy, with malignancy, tuberculosis and connective tissue disease. The pathology is fibrinous or serofibrinous inflammation, giving positional pleuritic chest pain, a friction rub, widespread saddle-shaped ST elevation with PR depression and, when it resolves, occasional constriction.
Effusion and tamponade depend on rate, not volume: a litre accumulating over months may be asymptomatic, while a rapidly bleeding 150 mL can be fatal. As intrapericardial pressure rises, all four chambers are compressed, filling becomes limited, the chambers compete for a fixed total volume (interventricular dependence), stroke volume falls and output is maintained only by tachycardia and vasoconstriction. Signs follow the physiology: raised venous pressure, quiet heart sounds, hypotension, pulsus paradoxus (exaggerated inspiratory fall in systolic pressure as the filling right ventricle encroaches on the left) and a raised venous pressure that fails to fall on inspiration (Kussmaul sign, more typical of constriction). Because filling depends on a pressure gradient into the heart, the patient is preload-dependent: vasodilatation, diuresis or positive pressure ventilation can precipitate arrest, and the treatment is drainage.
Constrictive pericarditis is a chronically thickened, fibrotic and often calcified pericardium (tuberculosis historically, now more often post-viral, post-surgical or post-radiotherapy) that limits filling in late diastole: a rapid early filling wave then an abrupt stop, with a pericardial knock, severe systemic venous congestion, ascites and a small quiet heart.
Making the answer flow
- Define heart failure as a syndrome, then classify it three ways before you discuss any mechanism.
- Explain each compensation and then why it becomes harmful; this is what examiners are listening for.
- For any valve lesion, answer in the order: cause, haemodynamic consequence, chamber adaptation, clinical consequence, and how the acute version differs.
- In tamponade, make the point that rate of accumulation matters more than volume, and explain pulsus paradoxus in terms of interventricular dependence.
Where marks are lost
- Equating heart failure with a low ejection fraction.
- Giving a vasodilator or a large dose of diuretic to a patient with tamponade or severe aortic stenosis without recognising preload dependence.
- Saying acute mitral regurgitation produces a loud murmur and a dilated atrium; it may be quiet with a normal-sized atrium.
- Forgetting that the commonest cause of right heart failure is left heart failure.
- Judging a pericardial effusion by its size alone.
Where this meets the emergency department
- Severe aortic stenosis and tamponade are both preload-dependent: a vasodilator, a large diuretic dose or an induction agent can stop the circulation.
- Flash pulmonary oedema with a quiet or absent murmur after an infarct suggests acute mitral regurgitation from chordal or papillary rupture.
Viva questions
Answer each one aloud, as you would to an examiner, before you open the model points.
- 1.
Define heart failure and classify it.
Show answer
- Syndrome where output is inadequate for demand, or adequate only with raised filling pressures.
- By ejection fraction: reduced (systolic) or preserved (diastolic).
- By side: left, right, or biventricular; left failure is the commonest cause of right failure.
- By time course: chronic, acutely decompensated, or acute de novo.
- 2.
Describe the compensatory mechanisms in heart failure and their drawbacks.
Show answer
- Frank-Starling: more filling raises output, but the curve is flat so congestion follows.
- Sympathetic activation: raises rate and contractility, but increases demand, downregulates receptors, is arrhythmogenic and toxic.
- Renin-angiotensin-aldosterone: restores pressure and volume, but raises preload and afterload and drives fibrosis.
- Hypertrophy and dilatation normalise wall stress initially, then outgrow capillary supply, fibrose and worsen geometry.
- Natriuretic peptides oppose these systems; blocking the harmful systems improves survival.
- 3.
Contrast concentric and eccentric hypertrophy.
Show answer
- Pressure overload raises systolic wall stress; sarcomeres added in parallel; thick wall, small stiff cavity; diastolic failure.
- Volume overload raises diastolic wall stress; sarcomeres added in series; dilated cavity; eventual systolic failure.
- Laplace law explains both: stress is proportional to pressure times radius over twice wall thickness.
- Examples: aortic stenosis and hypertension versus regurgitant lesions and shunts.
- 4.
Why does a patient with severe aortic stenosis faint on exertion?
Show answer
- Fixed outflow obstruction limits any rise in stroke volume.
- Exercise vasodilates skeletal muscle, so systemic resistance falls while output cannot rise; pressure falls.
- Contributing factors: arrhythmia, left ventricular baroreceptor activation, subendocardial ischaemia.
- Also preload-dependent and intolerant of tachycardia or loss of atrial contraction.
- 5.
How does acute mitral regurgitation differ from chronic?
Show answer
- Acute: papillary muscle or chordal rupture, or endocarditis; a non-compliant normal-sized atrium transmits pressure to the lungs, giving flash pulmonary oedema and shock.
- The murmur may be short or quiet because the pressure gradient equalises rapidly.
- Chronic: gradual atrial and ventricular dilatation with compliance, so years of compensation and late symptoms.
- Ejection fraction overestimates function in chronic regurgitation because of favourable loading.
- 6.
Classify the cardiomyopathies.
Show answer
- Dilated: systolic failure, four-chamber dilatation; idiopathic, genetic, alcohol, viral, peripartum, anthracycline, tachycardia-mediated.
- Hypertrophic: sarcomeric mutation, asymmetric septal hypertrophy, myocyte disarray, dynamic outflow obstruction, sudden death.
- Restrictive or infiltrative: amyloid, sarcoid, haemochromatosis, radiation.
- Arrhythmogenic right ventricular cardiomyopathy and stress cardiomyopathy as distinct entities.
- 7.
Explain the pathophysiology of cardiac tamponade.
Show answer
- Rising intrapericardial pressure compresses all chambers and limits diastolic filling.
- Rate of accumulation matters more than volume, because the pericardium stretches slowly but not quickly.
- Interventricular dependence: chambers compete for a fixed volume, producing pulsus paradoxus.
- Output maintained by tachycardia and vasoconstriction until decompensation; the patient is preload-dependent.
- Hazards: vasodilators, diuretics, positive pressure ventilation; treatment is drainage.
- 8.
What is constrictive pericarditis and how does it differ from restrictive cardiomyopathy?
Show answer
- Thickened fibrotic calcified pericardium limiting late diastolic filling; rapid early filling then abrupt stop, with a pericardial knock.
- Causes: post-viral, post-surgical, radiotherapy, tuberculosis.
- Restrictive cardiomyopathy is myocardial disease with impaired compliance throughout diastole and often raised natriuretic peptides and abnormal myocardial imaging.
- Distinction matters because constriction is surgically treatable by pericardiectomy.
Practise this week
Week 11 in the other subjects
- Anatomy: Leg, ankle and foot
- Pharmacology: Paracetamol, NSAIDs and other analgesics
- Physiology: Haemorrhage, posture and exercise
Not affiliated with the Australasian College for Emergency Medicine. Notes are a revision aid, not a substitute for the curriculum or for clinical guidelines.