Carbon dioxide transport and control of breathing
How carbon dioxide is carried in blood and why its dissociation curve differs from that of oxygen, the Haldane and Bohr effects, the central and peripheral chemoreceptors, the brainstem respiratory centres and the reflexes that modify breathing, the ventilatory response curves, and the physiology of hypercapnia and apnoea.
By the end of this page you should be able to
- Describe the forms in which carbon dioxide is carried and their relative contributions.
- Describe the carbon dioxide dissociation curve and contrast it with the oxygen curve.
- Explain the Haldane and Bohr effects and their role in gas exchange.
- Describe the central and peripheral chemoreceptors and what each senses.
- Describe the brainstem respiratory centres and the reflexes that modify breathing.
- Interpret the ventilatory response curves to carbon dioxide and to hypoxia, and explain the physiology of apnoea and of acute hypercapnia.
Carriage of carbon dioxide
- As bicarbonate, about 70 per cent. Carbon dioxide diffuses into the red cell, where carbonic anhydrase rapidly hydrates it to carbonic acid, which dissociates to bicarbonate and a hydrogen ion. Bicarbonate leaves the cell in exchange for chloride (the chloride shift, or Hamburger phenomenon) while the hydrogen ion is buffered by haemoglobin. Plasma lacks carbonic anhydrase, so most of this happens inside the red cell.
- As carbamino compounds, about 20 to 23 per cent, formed by carbon dioxide binding directly to terminal amino groups on haemoglobin, mostly on the deoxygenated form.
- Dissolved, about 7 to 10 per cent. This is a much larger fraction than for oxygen, because carbon dioxide is roughly 20 times more soluble, and it is the fraction the arterial carbon dioxide tension measures.
- Because most carriage depends on the red cell and on haemoglobin, the venous blood of an anaemic patient carries carbon dioxide less efficiently, and the buffering capacity of blood falls with the haemoglobin concentration.
The curve, the Haldane and the Bohr effects
The carbon dioxide dissociation curve is steeper and much more nearly linear than the oxygen curve over the physiological range. Two consequences matter. First, small changes in ventilation produce large changes in carbon dioxide content and tension, which is why carbon dioxide is tightly controlled and why hyperventilation lowers it quickly. Second, there is no plateau, so hypoventilating units cannot be compensated for by hyperventilating ones as easily for oxygen: in V/Q mismatch, increased ventilation to normal units can correct the carbon dioxide, because the curve is linear, whereas it cannot correct the oxygen, because the curve is flat at the top.
The Haldane effect is the influence of oxygenation on carbon dioxide carriage: deoxygenated haemoglobin binds carbon dioxide and hydrogen ions more readily, because it is a weaker acid and a better carbamino former. In the tissues, giving up oxygen therefore helps the blood take up carbon dioxide, and in the lung, taking up oxygen helps it release carbon dioxide. It roughly doubles the amount of carbon dioxide carried for a given change in tension.
The Bohr effect is the mirror image: raised carbon dioxide and hydrogen ion concentration reduce haemoglobin oxygen affinity, shifting the dissociation curve right, so oxygen is unloaded more readily in metabolically active tissue.
The two effects work together in the same capillary, which is why gas exchange is more efficient than either curve alone suggests. A clinically important corollary is that in a patient who is hyperventilating with a very low carbon dioxide, the curve is shifted left and oxygen unloading at the tissues is impaired, and cerebral vessels constrict as well.
Chemoreceptors
- Central chemoreceptors lie in the ventral medulla, near the surface, bathed in cerebrospinal fluid. They respond to hydrogen ion concentration, not to carbon dioxide directly, but because carbon dioxide crosses the blood brain barrier freely while hydrogen ions and bicarbonate do not, they act effectively as carbon dioxide sensors. They account for roughly 80 per cent of the ventilatory response to carbon dioxide, act over minutes, and are not oxygen sensors.
- Because cerebrospinal fluid has little protein buffer, a rise in carbon dioxide produces a brisk fall in its pH. Over one to two days, choroid plexus transport of bicarbonate restores the pH, and the receptors reset: this is the mechanism of compensation in chronic carbon dioxide retention, and it explains why chronic retainers depend relatively more on hypoxic drive.
- Peripheral chemoreceptors are the carotid bodies (at the bifurcation, afferents in the glossopharyngeal nerve) and the aortic bodies (vagal afferents). They are the only sensors of oxygen tension in the body. Their firing increases steeply once the arterial oxygen tension falls below about 60 mmHg, and they also respond, more weakly and more rapidly than the central receptors, to carbon dioxide, hydrogen ions, hypoperfusion and temperature.
- They sense tension, not content, which is why they are not stimulated by anaemia or by carbon monoxide poisoning: the patient is profoundly hypoxic at the tissue level but is not breathless from chemoreceptor drive.
Central control and reflexes
- Medullary centres: the dorsal respiratory group (largely inspiratory, in the nucleus tractus solitarius, receiving chemoreceptor, vagal and glossopharyngeal input) and the ventral respiratory group (both inspiratory and expiratory, driving the forced expiratory muscles). The pre-Botzinger complex within the ventral group is the rhythm generator, and it is the target of opioid-induced respiratory depression.
- Reflexes: the Hering-Breuer inflation reflex (stretch receptor afferents in the vagus limiting inspiration, important in neonates and at large tidal volumes), irritant receptor responses (cough, bronchoconstriction, laryngospasm), J (juxtacapillary) receptors (stimulated by interstitial oedema and emboli, causing rapid shallow breathing and the sensation of breathlessness), proprioceptive input from muscles and joints at the start of exercise, the diving reflex (apnoea, bradycardia and vasoconstriction with cold water on the face) and pain and temperature effects.
- Exercise ventilation rises almost exactly in proportion to carbon dioxide production, yet the arterial carbon dioxide does not change measurably, so the drive cannot be chemoreceptor-mediated alone: central command, muscle and joint afferents and oscillations in carbon dioxide are all implicated. This is a classic viva question, and the honest answer is that the mechanism is multifactorial and incompletely understood.
Response curves, apnoea and hypercapnia
The carbon dioxide response curve plots minute ventilation against arterial carbon dioxide. It is steep and nearly linear: ventilation rises by roughly 2 to 3 L/min for every 1 mmHg rise in carbon dioxide, starting from an apnoeic threshold just below the resting value. The curve is steepened by hypoxia (peripheral chemoreceptor input adds to central drive) and metabolic acidosis, and is flattened and shifted right by opioids and sedatives, by sleep, by chronic retention and by anything that increases the work of breathing to the point of mechanical limitation. This single curve explains most of what happens clinically: why an opioid-sedated patient allows carbon dioxide to climb, why a patient with chronic retention does not mount the expected response, and why hypoxia makes everyone breathe harder for the same carbon dioxide.
The hypoxic response curve is different in shape: ventilation rises little until the oxygen tension falls below about 60 mmHg, then rises steeply. It is augmented by hypercapnia, blunted by chronic hypoxia and by some drugs, and abolished by bilateral carotid body denervation.
Apnoea physiology brings the two together. The time to desaturation after apnoea depends on the oxygen store, which is essentially the functional residual capacity multiplied by the oxygen fraction within it, and on the rate of consumption. Preoxygenation replaces alveolar nitrogen with oxygen and can extend safe apnoea time severalfold; the patients in whom it fails are those with a small store (obesity, pregnancy, supine position), a high consumption (sepsis, agitation), or shunt. Meanwhile carbon dioxide rises predictably, by a few millimetres of mercury in the first minute and then steadily, with the associated fall in pH, which is why prolonged apnoeic oxygenation protects the saturation but not the acid-base state.
Acute hypercapnia has consequences beyond acidosis: cerebral vasodilatation with raised intracranial pressure and eventually narcosis, sympathetic activation with tachycardia, sweating and hypertension (then depression at extreme levels), pulmonary vasoconstriction, hyperkalaemia and a right shift of the oxygen curve. In the chronically hypercapnic patient, giving a high concentration of oxygen can raise the carbon dioxide further, predominantly by reversing hypoxic pulmonary vasoconstriction and so worsening V/Q matching and dead space, with the Haldane effect and a modest reduction in hypoxic drive also contributing. The practical conclusion is not to withhold oxygen from a hypoxic patient, but to titrate it to a target saturation and watch the ventilation.
Making the answer flow
- Give the three forms of carriage with percentages, and say where carbonic anhydrase is.
- Define the Haldane and Bohr effects in one sentence each and say where each operates.
- Separate what the central and peripheral chemoreceptors sense, and make the point that only the peripheral ones sense oxygen tension.
- Draw the carbon dioxide response curve and shift it for hypoxia, opioids and chronic retention; it answers many questions at once.
- In hypercapnia with oxygen therapy, lead with V/Q change rather than loss of hypoxic drive.
Where marks are lost
- Saying central chemoreceptors sense carbon dioxide directly; they sense hydrogen ions.
- Saying the peripheral chemoreceptors respond to oxygen content; they respond to tension, which is why anaemia and carbon monoxide do not stimulate them.
- Reversing the Bohr and Haldane effects.
- Attributing oxygen-induced hypercapnia solely to loss of hypoxic drive.
- Forgetting that apnoeic oxygenation maintains saturation while carbon dioxide and acidosis continue to worsen.
Where this meets the emergency department
- Preoxygenation buys apnoea time by filling the functional residual capacity with oxygen, but the carbon dioxide and the pH keep worsening throughout.
- Oxygen-induced hypercapnia is mostly a V/Q effect, so titrate to a target saturation rather than withholding oxygen from a hypoxic patient.
Viva questions
Answer each one aloud, as you would to an examiner, before you open the model points.
- 1.
How is carbon dioxide carried in the blood?
Show answer
- About 70 per cent as bicarbonate, formed inside the red cell by carbonic anhydrase, with the chloride shift and buffering of hydrogen ions by haemoglobin.
- About 20 to 23 per cent as carbamino compounds on haemoglobin, mostly the deoxygenated form.
- About 7 to 10 per cent dissolved, a larger fraction than for oxygen because of greater solubility.
- Carriage and buffering therefore depend on red cell mass and haemoglobin.
- 2.
Contrast the carbon dioxide and oxygen dissociation curves.
Show answer
- Carbon dioxide curve is steeper and nearly linear over the physiological range; the oxygen curve is sigmoid with a plateau.
- Small ventilation changes alter carbon dioxide substantially, so it is tightly controlled.
- In V/Q mismatch, hyperventilating normal units can normalise carbon dioxide but not oxygen, because of the flat upper oxygen curve.
- Venous to arterial difference is small for carbon dioxide in tension but significant in content.
- 3.
Explain the Haldane and Bohr effects.
Show answer
- Haldane: deoxygenated haemoglobin binds carbon dioxide and hydrogen ions more readily, so tissue unloading of oxygen promotes carbon dioxide uptake, and lung oxygenation promotes its release.
- Bohr: raised carbon dioxide and hydrogen ion concentration reduce haemoglobin oxygen affinity, shifting the curve right and aiding tissue unloading.
- Both operate simultaneously in the same capillary, improving the efficiency of exchange.
- Clinical corollary: marked hypocapnia shifts the curve left and impairs unloading, as well as constricting cerebral vessels.
- 4.
Describe the chemoreceptors and what each senses.
Show answer
- Central: ventral medulla, respond to hydrogen ions generated from carbon dioxide crossing the blood brain barrier; about 80 per cent of the carbon dioxide response; no oxygen sensing.
- Peripheral: carotid bodies with glossopharyngeal afferents, aortic bodies with vagal afferents; the only oxygen sensors; respond steeply below about 60 mmHg.
- Peripheral receptors also respond to carbon dioxide, hydrogen ions and hypoperfusion, and act faster.
- Central receptors reset over one to two days by cerebrospinal fluid bicarbonate transport.
- 5.
Describe the brainstem control of breathing.
Show answer
- Dorsal respiratory group in the nucleus tractus solitarius: mainly inspiratory, receives chemoreceptor and vagal afferents.
- Ventral respiratory group: inspiratory and expiratory, drives forced expiration; pre-Botzinger complex generates rhythm.
- Pontine pneumotaxic centre limits inspiration and sets rate; apneustic centre promotes it.
- Cortical and limbic input allows voluntary and emotional modulation.
- 6.
Draw the carbon dioxide response curve and describe what shifts it.
Show answer
- Minute ventilation against arterial carbon dioxide; steep and nearly linear, rising about 2 to 3 L/min per mmHg from an apnoeic threshold.
- Steepened by hypoxia and metabolic acidosis.
- Flattened and shifted right by opioids, sedatives, anaesthesia, sleep, chronic retention and mechanical limitation.
- Explains opioid hypoventilation, blunted response in chronic retainers, and increased drive during hypoxia.
- 7.
What determines how long a patient can tolerate apnoea?
Show answer
- The oxygen store, essentially functional residual capacity times the alveolar oxygen fraction, and the rate of consumption.
- Preoxygenation replaces nitrogen with oxygen and can extend safe apnoea time considerably.
- Shortened by reduced functional residual capacity (obesity, pregnancy, supine position), high consumption (sepsis, agitation), shunt and anaemia.
- Carbon dioxide rises and pH falls throughout, so apnoeic oxygenation protects saturation but not acid-base status.
- 8.
Why can oxygen therapy raise the carbon dioxide in a patient with chronic retention?
Show answer
- Mainly by reversing hypoxic pulmonary vasoconstriction, so blood returns to poorly ventilated lung, worsening V/Q matching and increasing dead space.
- The Haldane effect: oxygenated haemoglobin releases carbon dioxide, raising its tension.
- A modest reduction in hypoxic ventilatory drive, which is a smaller contributor than traditionally taught.
- Management: do not withhold oxygen from a hypoxic patient, but titrate to a target saturation and monitor ventilation and gases.
Practise this week
Week 15 in the other subjects
- Anatomy: Abdominal wall, inguinal region and peritoneum
- Pathology: Obstructive and restrictive lung disease, pulmonary embolism
- Pharmacology: Antipsychotics, antidepressants and lithium
Not affiliated with the Australasian College for Emergency Medicine. Notes are a revision aid, not a substitute for the curriculum or for clinical guidelines.