Lung mechanics and the work of breathing
The pressures and muscles that move air, elastic recoil and surfactant, compliance and the pressure-volume curve, airway resistance and dynamic compression, the lung volumes and what functional residual capacity defends, and how the work of breathing is divided and minimised.
By the end of this page you should be able to
- Describe the pressures and muscles involved in quiet and forced breathing.
- Explain elastic recoil, surface tension and the actions of surfactant.
- Define compliance, interpret the pressure-volume curve and explain hysteresis.
- Describe airway resistance, where it is greatest, and the mechanism of dynamic airway compression and flow limitation.
- Define the lung volumes and capacities and explain the importance of functional residual capacity and closing capacity.
- Divide the work of breathing and explain how the pattern of breathing minimises it.
Pressures and muscles
Air flows because the alveolar pressure is made lower than the atmosphere. The intrapleural pressure is subatmospheric (about minus 5 cmH2O at the end of a quiet expiration, falling to about minus 8 in inspiration) because the elastic lung recoils inwards while the chest wall recoils outwards.
Two differences matter. Transpulmonary pressure (alveolar minus intrapleural) is the distending pressure of the lung, and it is what keeps alveoli open. Transthoracic pressure describes the chest wall. At functional residual capacity, the inward pull of the lung and the outward pull of the chest wall are equal and opposite, and the respiratory system is at rest.
Quiet inspiration is active, almost entirely by the diaphragm (about two thirds of tidal volume, by descending a centimetre or two) with the external intercostals; quiet expiration is passive, driven by stored elastic recoil. In forced breathing the accessory muscles (sternocleidomastoid, scalenes, pectorals) and the muscles of expiration (abdominal wall, internal intercostals) are recruited. The abdominal muscles also contribute by raising abdominal pressure to push the diaphragm up, and they are essential for coughing, which is why a high cervical or thoracic cord injury impairs clearance of secretions even when the diaphragm works.
In positive pressure ventilation the sign of the pressures reverses: alveolar and intrapleural pressures become positive in inspiration, which is why venous return falls and why the risk of barotrauma exists.
Elastic recoil and surfactant
- Two things make the lung recoil: elastin and collagen in the tissue, and the surface tension of the air-liquid interface, which accounts for about two thirds of the recoil.
- Laplace law for a bubble states that the collapsing pressure is proportional to surface tension and inversely proportional to radius. Without a change in surface tension, small alveoli would empty into large ones.
- Surfactant, secreted by type II pneumocytes and composed largely of dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine with surfactant proteins, lowers surface tension and, crucially, does so more at low lung volume than at high, because the molecules are more densely packed when the alveolar surface is small. The effects are: higher compliance and lower work of breathing, stability of alveoli of different sizes, reduced tendency to transudate fluid into the alveolus, and a contribution to innate immunity.
- Alveolar interdependence adds mechanical stability, because adjacent alveoli share walls and a collapsing unit is held open by its neighbours.
- Loss of surfactant (prematurity, the acute respiratory distress syndrome, aspiration, drowning, prolonged high oxygen exposure, ischaemia) produces stiff lungs, atelectasis, shunt and oedema. Antenatal corticosteroids and exogenous surfactant work directly on this mechanism.
Compliance and the pressure-volume curve
- Compliance is the change in volume per unit change in pressure: the slope of the pressure-volume curve, normally about 200 mL per cmH2O for the lung alone and about 100 for the lung and chest wall together.
- Static compliance is measured with no flow, at a plateau pressure; dynamic compliance is measured during flow and therefore includes a resistive component. The difference between peak and plateau airway pressure in a ventilated patient reflects resistance, while a high plateau pressure reflects low compliance: that single comparison separates bronchospasm or a blocked tube from pneumothorax, oedema or abdominal distension.
- The curve is sigmoid: flat at low volume (collapsed alveoli needing recruitment), steep in the middle (the normal operating range and the safest place to ventilate), and flat again at high volume (an already stretched lung, where further pressure achieves little and risks injury).
- Hysteresis is the difference between the inflation and deflation limbs, caused by surfactant behaviour and by recruitment, so a higher pressure is needed to open a unit than to keep it open. This is the physiological basis of recruitment manoeuvres followed by positive end-expiratory pressure.
- Reduced compliance: fibrosis, pulmonary oedema, consolidation, atelectasis, surfactant deficiency, raised pulmonary venous pressure, and extrapulmonary causes (obesity, raised intra-abdominal pressure, kyphoscoliosis, circumferential burns, pain and splinting). Increased compliance: emphysema and normal ageing, where elastic tissue is lost, so the lung is easy to inflate but recoils poorly.
Resistance and flow limitation
- Resistance is pressure difference divided by flow. In laminar flow the Hagen-Poiseuille relationship applies, so radius dominates; in the turbulent flow of the large airways, the pressure needed rises with the square of flow, and density matters, which is the basis of helium-oxygen mixtures in upper airway obstruction.
- Most resistance lies in the medium-sized bronchi, not in the small airways: although each bronchiole is narrow, there are so many in parallel that their combined resistance is small. This is why small airway disease can be advanced before it is clinically obvious.
- Resistance falls as lung volume rises, because radial traction from surrounding tissue holds airways open; hence pursed-lip breathing, the use of positive end-expiratory pressure and the preference for sitting upright.
- Dynamic airway compression: during forced expiration, pleural pressure becomes positive and compresses the airway. The equal pressure point is where airway pressure equals pleural pressure, and downstream of it the airway is compressed. Beyond a modest effort, flow therefore becomes effort-independent: trying harder does not increase flow, which is why peak flow measures airway calibre and why patients with airflow limitation gain nothing from forcing expiration.
- In emphysema, loss of elastic recoil moves the equal pressure point towards the alveolus and removes radial traction, so airways collapse early. This causes gas trapping, intrinsic positive end-expiratory pressure and hyperinflation, with a flattened diaphragm that works at a mechanical disadvantage.
Volumes and the work of breathing
Volumes: tidal volume (about 500 mL), inspiratory and expiratory reserve volumes, and residual volume. Capacities are sums of volumes: inspiratory capacity, functional residual capacity (expiratory reserve plus residual volume, about 2.5 to 3 L), vital capacity and total lung capacity. Residual volume, and so functional residual capacity and total lung capacity, cannot be measured by spirometry; they need helium dilution, nitrogen washout or body plethysmography.
Functional residual capacity matters because it is the oxygen store that determines how long apnoea can be tolerated, and because it keeps small airways open and smooths the oscillation in alveolar gas tensions between breaths. It is reduced by lying supine, obesity, pregnancy, anaesthesia and paralysis, abdominal distension and thoracic restriction, which is why these patients desaturate quickly and why head-up positioning and preoxygenation matter.
Closing capacity is the lung volume at which dependent small airways begin to close. It rises with age and with smoking. When closing capacity exceeds functional residual capacity, airways close during normal tidal breathing, producing shunt and hypoxaemia; this is the mechanism behind the fall in arterial oxygen with age and much of the hypoxaemia of anaesthesia.
Dead space is ventilation that does not take part in gas exchange: anatomical (the conducting airways, about 2 mL per kg), alveolar (ventilated but unperfused alveoli), and physiological, the sum of the two.
Work of breathing is pressure times volume change, and is divided into elastic work (overcoming tissue and surface forces; stored and then returned in passive expiration) and resistive work (overcoming airway and tissue friction; lost as heat). It accounts for only a few per cent of resting oxygen consumption, but can reach a quarter or more in severe respiratory distress, which is one reason a patient tires. The two components vary oppositely with respiratory rate: slow deep breathing costs more elastic work, rapid shallow breathing costs more resistive work and wastes more ventilation on dead space. The body selects the rate that minimises total work, which is why patients with stiff lungs breathe rapidly and shallowly and patients with airflow obstruction breathe slowly and deeply.
Making the answer flow
- Define the pressures precisely and say what transpulmonary pressure does; much of this topic follows from it.
- Give surfactant three jobs: compliance, alveolar stability and keeping the alveolus dry.
- Use the peak minus plateau pressure comparison to show you can apply compliance and resistance at the bedside.
- Explain effort-independent flow with the equal pressure point, then apply it to emphysema.
- Finish the work of breathing with why pattern differs between restrictive and obstructive disease.
Where marks are lost
- Saying most airway resistance is in the small airways.
- Describing compliance as a pressure rather than a slope, or quoting lung compliance without saying whether the chest wall is included.
- Saying surfactant lowers surface tension equally at all volumes; the variation with surface area is the point.
- Forgetting that residual volume cannot be measured by spirometry.
- Thinking harder effort increases expiratory flow once flow limitation is reached.
Where this meets intensive care
- When airway pressure rises on a volume-controlled ventilator, an inspiratory hold separates the causes: a high peak with a normal plateau is resistance (tube, secretions, bronchospasm); a high plateau is compliance (lung, chest wall, abdomen).
- PEEP moves a collapsed lung up its pressure-volume curve so that tidal breaths occur on the steep part; too much moves it onto the flat upper part, overdistending alveoli and raising dead space.
Viva questions
Answer each one aloud, as you would to an examiner, before you open the model points.
- 1.
Define the pressures involved in breathing.
Show answer
- Intrapleural pressure: subatmospheric, about minus 5 cmH2O at end expiration, more negative in inspiration.
- Alveolar pressure: zero at end expiration, negative during inspiration in spontaneous breathing.
- Transpulmonary pressure: alveolar minus intrapleural, the distending pressure of the lung.
- At functional residual capacity, inward lung recoil balances outward chest wall recoil.
- Positive pressure ventilation reverses the sign, reducing venous return.
- 2.
What does surfactant do and where does it come from?
Show answer
- Secreted by type II pneumocytes; mainly dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine with surfactant proteins.
- Lowers surface tension, and does so more at low lung volume because of molecular packing.
- Increases compliance, reduces work of breathing, stabilises alveoli of different sizes, keeps the alveolus dry, and contributes to innate immunity.
- Deficiency in prematurity and in acute respiratory distress syndrome causes atelectasis, shunt and oedema.
- 3.
Define compliance and describe the pressure-volume curve.
Show answer
- Change in volume per unit change in pressure; about 200 mL per cmH2O for the lung, 100 for lung plus chest wall.
- Sigmoid: flat at low volume where alveoli are collapsed, steep in the normal range, flat at high volume where the lung is stretched.
- Hysteresis between inflation and deflation limbs due to surfactant and recruitment.
- Static versus dynamic compliance; specific compliance corrects for lung volume.
- 4.
A ventilated patient suddenly has a high peak airway pressure. How does respiratory mechanics help you?
Show answer
- Compare peak and plateau pressures: a high peak with a normal plateau indicates a resistance problem, a high plateau indicates reduced compliance.
- Resistance problems: blocked or kinked tube, secretions, bronchospasm, tube in a bronchus.
- Compliance problems: pneumothorax, pulmonary oedema, consolidation, atelectasis, abdominal distension, chest wall problem.
- Also consider breath stacking with intrinsic positive end-expiratory pressure; disconnect and give time to exhale.
- 5.
Where is airway resistance greatest, and what changes it?
Show answer
- Greatest in the medium-sized bronchi; small airways contribute little because of their vast parallel cross-section.
- Falls as lung volume rises because of radial traction.
- Raised by bronchoconstriction, secretions, oedema, foreign body, external compression and turbulent flow.
- Lowered by beta-2 agonism, higher lung volume, and reducing gas density in upper airway obstruction.
- 6.
Explain dynamic airway compression and its significance in emphysema.
Show answer
- Forced expiration makes pleural pressure positive; beyond the equal pressure point the airway is compressed.
- Flow becomes effort-independent, so greater effort does not raise flow.
- Emphysema reduces elastic recoil and radial traction, moving the equal pressure point towards the alveolus and causing early airway collapse.
- Results in gas trapping, intrinsic positive end-expiratory pressure, hyperinflation and a mechanically disadvantaged flat diaphragm.
- 7.
Why does functional residual capacity matter, and what reduces it?
Show answer
- It is the oxygen reservoir that determines tolerance of apnoea, keeps small airways open and buffers alveolar gas tensions.
- Reduced by supine position, obesity, pregnancy, anaesthesia and paralysis, abdominal distension and thoracic restriction.
- When closing capacity exceeds it, airways close during tidal breathing, producing shunt and hypoxaemia.
- Clinical response: head-up position, preoxygenation, positive end-expiratory pressure and recruitment.
- 8.
How is the work of breathing divided, and why do restrictive and obstructive patients breathe differently?
Show answer
- Elastic work overcomes tissue and surface forces and is stored for passive expiration; resistive work overcomes friction and is lost as heat.
- Normally a few per cent of oxygen consumption, rising greatly in respiratory distress.
- Slow deep breathing increases elastic work; rapid shallow breathing increases resistive work and dead space ventilation.
- Stiff lungs favour rapid shallow breaths; airflow obstruction favours slow deep breaths with prolonged expiration.
Practise this week
- Ventilator Waveform Reader
- Physiology Bench: move the graphs yourself
- First Part SAQs, marked part by part
- First Part cross-table vivas
- Viva Examiner: practise answering aloud
Week 3 in the other subjects
- Pharmacology: Metabolism, interactions and safe prescribing
- Measurement: Gas laws, flow and oxygen delivery
Not affiliated with the CICM. Notes are a revision aid, not a substitute for the curriculum or for clinical guidelines.