FRANZCOG SAQ Example: Ectopic Pregnancy with Model Answer
This is an original practice question in the style of a FRANZCOG Written Examination SAQ. It is not a recalled exam question. Give yourself about 20 minutes, type your answer as you would on the day, and only then read the model answer.
The question
A 31-year-old woman, G2P1, presents to the early pregnancy assessment service with light vaginal bleeding and mild left iliac fossa pain. Her last menstrual period was 6 weeks and 2 days ago. She is haemodynamically stable with mild left adnexal tenderness and no peritonism. Transvaginal ultrasound shows no intrauterine pregnancy, a 22 mm inhomogeneous left adnexal mass separate from the ovary with no fetal heart activity, and a small amount of free fluid in the pouch of Douglas. Her serum hCG is 1,150 IU/L. She is breastfeeding her 9-month-old.
Part A: What is the most likely diagnosis, and what are her management options? (6 marks) Part B: Which option would you recommend, and why? (4 marks) Part C: What counselling would you give before discharge? (5 marks)
Model answer: Part A
- Most likely diagnosis: left tubal ectopic pregnancy, unruptured, in a haemodynamically stable woman.
- Expectant management: suitable for selected women who are stable, have minimal pain and a low and falling hCG, with reliable follow-up; involves serial hCG until negative.
- Medical management: intramuscular methotrexate in a single-dose protocol, for stable women with an unruptured mass, no fetal heart activity, a low hCG and no contraindications, who can attend follow-up.
- Surgical management: laparoscopy, usually salpingectomy if the contralateral tube looks healthy; salpingotomy may be considered if the other tube is damaged and fertility is a priority, with hCG follow-up for persistent trophoblast.
- Baseline assessment before any option: full blood count, renal and liver function, blood group and antibody screen; Rh D status to guide anti-D according to current Australian guidelines.
- Shared decision-making, documenting the discussion and her choice.
Model answer: Part B
- On the ultrasound and hCG alone she would be a candidate for medical management.
- However, she is breastfeeding, which is a contraindication to methotrexate.
- Options are therefore expectant management, if she is willing and the hCG is falling on repeat testing, or laparoscopic salpingectomy.
- Recommend: discuss both. If her repeat hCG at 48 hours is falling and she has minimal pain and can return promptly, expectant management is reasonable. If the hCG is plateauing or rising, her pain increases, or she prefers definitive treatment, laparoscopic salpingectomy.
- Respect her preference, and explain the trade-offs: expectant management avoids surgery but involves repeated visits and a small risk of rupture; surgery is definitive but carries operative and anaesthetic risks.
Model answer: Part C
- Warning signs of rupture, in plain language: worsening abdominal or shoulder tip pain, dizziness or fainting, heavy bleeding. Return to the emergency department immediately if any occur.
- Follow-up plan: when and where her next hCG will be taken, and that follow-up continues until the hCG is negative.
- Avoid intercourse and strenuous activity until the hCG is falling and pain has settled.
- Contraception until she is ready to conceive again, and early ultrasound in a future pregnancy because of her increased risk of recurrent ectopic.
- Emotional support: acknowledge the loss of the pregnancy, offer contact details for support services and check on her partner.
- Written information and a contact number for the early pregnancy service.
Where the marks are
- The breastfeeding detail. It is in the stem to test whether you check contraindications before reaching for methotrexate. Candidates who recommend methotrexate without noticing lose most of Part B.
- Structured options in Part A. Expectant, medical and surgical, each with its own criteria, is the shape markers expect.
- Salpingectomy versus salpingotomy. Stating the role of the contralateral tube shows judgement, not just knowledge.
- Rh D status. A short line on anti-D according to current guidelines is easy to miss.
- Counselling that sounds like counselling. Warning signs in words she will understand, a clear follow-up plan, and acknowledging the loss.
Common weak answers
The most common weak answer recommends methotrexate on the numbers, gives the regimen in detail, and never mentions breastfeeding. It looks knowledgeable and scores poorly. The second is a Part C that lists medical facts ('hCG on day 4 and 7') with no warning signs, no emotional support and no future pregnancy advice.
Practise the variations
Rewrite the stem and answer again. Make her not breastfeeding with an hCG of 1,150: now methotrexate becomes a strong option and Part C must cover methotrexate side effects, avoiding folate and alcohol, and delaying conception afterwards. Make her haemodynamically unstable: now it is a resuscitation and theatre question. Practising how the answer changes is what makes the structure automatic.
Fellowship Ready has a bank of original FRANZCOG-style SAQs like this one, marked point by point for structure and content. You can start free, no card needed.
Try 20 free questions.
RANZCOG-style questions, marked with a reason for every option. Free account, no card.
Free, no sign-up: scroll a real CT, head to pelvis →
Next: How to Pass the FRANZCOG Written and Oral Exams →
Next: FRANZCOG SAQ Technique: How to Write Answers That Score →
Next: FRANZCOG Oral Exam: Technique for the 12 OSCE Stations →
Not affiliated with RANZCOG.