Sample · AFRM
Severe TBI in inpatient rehab: PTA, agitation, heterotopic ossification, driving and work
Traumatic brain injury · 5 parts · 23 marks. Decide what you would write, then compare with the rubric and model answer. In the app you write it under time and it comes back marked.
Liam, a 24-year-old apprentice electrician, was the rider in a motorcycle crash in regional Victoria 19 days ago. His Glasgow Coma Scale score at the scene was 6. He was intubated for five days and has now been transferred to your inpatient brain injury rehabilitation unit. The Transport Accident Commission has accepted his claim.
His day-one computed tomography (CT) scan of the brain was reported as: haemorrhagic contusions in both inferior (orbital) frontal lobes and the left anterior temporal pole; several small petechial haemorrhages at the grey-white matter junction of both frontal lobes and in the splenium of the corpus callosum; a thin (4 mm) left acute subdural haematoma with no midline shift; and a small amount of traumatic subarachnoid blood in the basal cisterns. He had a right clavicle fracture managed non-operatively.
On arrival he is awake, mobilising with one assist, restless, disoriented to time and place, and asks the same questions repeatedly. He lives with his partner and was planning to marry next year.
(a) Interpret the computed tomography findings and outline what they predict about the cognitive and behavioural problems you expect. 4 marks
Show the rubric and model answer
- Orbitofrontal and anterior temporal contusions: typical sites where the brain strikes the orbital roofs and sphenoid wing (acceleration-deceleration, coup-contrecoup) (1)
- Petechial haemorrhages at grey-white junction and splenium of corpus callosum indicate diffuse axonal injury (corpus callosum involvement = at least Adams grade 2); CT underestimates it, magnetic resonance imaging with susceptibility-weighted sequences is more sensitive (1)
- Predicts executive dysfunction, disinhibition, impulsivity, irritability, poor insight, apathy (orbitofrontal) (1)
- Predicts memory and new-learning impairment and possible word-finding problems (left temporal); slowed information processing and attention deficits (diffuse axonal injury) (1)
- Other implications: anosmia (olfactory tract over orbitofrontal surface), raised risk of post-traumatic epilepsy (contusions plus subdural blood); small subdural and subarachnoid blood unlikely to need intervention but warrant monitoring (1)
The pattern is a moderate-severe acceleration-deceleration injury with focal and diffuse components.
- Focal: contusions in both orbitofrontal lobes and the left temporal pole are the classic sites where the brain is driven against the bony orbital roofs and sphenoid wing.
- Diffuse: petechial haemorrhages at the grey-white junction and in the splenium of the corpus callosum indicate diffuse axonal injury (corpus callosum involvement is at least Adams grade 2). Computed tomography underestimates diffuse axonal injury; magnetic resonance imaging with susceptibility-weighted imaging would show its extent if it would change management or prognostic counselling.
- Thin subdural haematoma and basal subarachnoid blood without mass effect: unlikely to need surgery, but they add to seizure risk.
Expected problems:
- Orbitofrontal: disinhibition, impulsivity, irritability, poor self-monitoring and insight, emotional lability, socially inappropriate behaviour; apathy is also possible.
- Left anterior temporal: impaired verbal memory and new learning, word-finding difficulty.
- Diffuse axonal injury: slowed processing speed, reduced attention and divided attention, fatigue.
- Anosmia from shearing of the olfactory tracts (relevant to safety and appetite, and to his work as an electrician, for example detecting burning).
- Increased risk of late post-traumatic seizures (cortical contusions and subdural blood are recognised risk factors).
(b) Outline how you would assess and monitor his post-traumatic amnesia, and its prognostic significance. 5 marks
Show the rubric and model answer
- Post-traumatic amnesia defined: period after injury of confusion, disorientation and inability to lay down continuous day-to-day memories (1)
- Westmead Post-Traumatic Amnesia Scale administered daily, at a consistent time, by trained staff: orientation questions plus recall of examiner face, name and three picture cards; total 12 (1)
- Emergence criterion: perfect score (12/12) on three consecutive days; post-traumatic amnesia ends on the first of those days; duration counted from injury (1)
- Duration is the best early predictor of outcome: more than 4 weeks = extremely severe injury (Russell and Smith classification, with 1-7 days severe, 1-4 weeks very severe) (1)
- Longer post-traumatic amnesia predicts poorer functional independence, return to work and driving outcomes and longer length of stay (1)
- Management implications during post-traumatic amnesia: consistent staff and routine, low stimulation, orientation aids, avoid formal therapy that relies on new learning, defer formal neuropsychological testing and consent-dependent decisions (1)
Post-traumatic amnesia is the period after injury in which the person is confused and disoriented and cannot form continuous day-to-day memories. Liam's repetitive questioning and disorientation suggest he is still in it on day 19.
Assessment and monitoring:
- Westmead Post-Traumatic Amnesia Scale every day, at the same time of day, by trained nursing or therapy staff. It has seven orientation questions and five memory items (the examiner's face and name and three picture cards shown the previous day), total 12.
- He is out of post-traumatic amnesia when he scores 12/12 on three consecutive days. The end date is the first of those three days, and duration is counted from the day of injury.
- Record behaviour alongside, using the Agitated Behaviour Scale, because agitation and post-traumatic amnesia often go together.
- Do not substitute a general cognitive screen, and do not confuse post-traumatic amnesia with sedation or a superimposed delirium (look for infection, drugs and seizures if the scores fluctuate or go backwards).
Prognostic significance:
- Duration of post-traumatic amnesia is one of the strongest early predictors of outcome. On the Russell and Smith classification: less than 1 day moderate, 1-7 days severe, 1-4 weeks very severe, more than 4 weeks extremely severe. Liam is already at 19 days, so at least very severe.
- Longer post-traumatic amnesia predicts lower functional independence at discharge, longer length of stay, and lower likelihood of returning to work and driving. It is a guide for the family, not a certainty for an individual.
Practical implications while in post-traumatic amnesia: consistent staff, structured routine, low-stimulation environment, orientation boards, family education, no formal neuropsychological testing yet, and defer significant decisions that need his capacity.
Over the next week Liam becomes increasingly agitated, especially in the evening. He has pulled out his peripheral cannula twice, tried to leave the ward, and struck a nurse. His Agitated Behaviour Scale scores are 34-38. He remains in post-traumatic amnesia.
(c) Describe your management of his agitation. 5 marks
Show the rubric and model answer
- Recognise agitation as expected in post-traumatic amnesia; quantify and track with Agitated Behaviour Scale (14 items, score 14-56; above 35 severe) (1)
- Search for and treat contributors: pain (clavicle fracture), constipation, urinary retention, infection, hypoxia, sleep disruption, seizures, nicotine/alcohol/drug withdrawal, deliriogenic medicines (1)
- Environmental: single low-stimulus room, consistent staff, one-to-one nursing, enclosed or low-floor bed, remove unnecessary lines, sleep-wake routine, limit visitors to one or two familiar people, safe wandering area (1)
- Behavioural: calm brief communication, do not argue or reorient forcefully, redirect, predictable schedule, staff training and debriefing (1)
- Pharmacological only when needed, start low and review: propranolol has the best evidence; alternatives valproate or carbamazepine; low-dose quetiapine; avoid routine haloperidol and benzodiazepines (may impair recovery and prolong confusion) (1)
- Restrictive practice and consent: least restrictive option, legal authority under Victorian law via his medical treatment decision maker, documentation, staff safety and incident reporting (1)
Agitation is common during post-traumatic amnesia and usually settles as he emerges, so the aim is safety while recovery happens, using the least restrictive means.
1. Measure it: Agitated Behaviour Scale every shift (14 items, total 14-56; scores above 35 are severe), with a behaviour chart to find triggers and the time-of-day pattern.
2. Treat contributors: pain from the clavicle fracture (regular paracetamol), constipation, urinary retention (bladder scan), infection, hypoxia, poor sleep, seizures (consider electroencephalography if fluctuating), withdrawal from nicotine (offer patches), alcohol or other drugs, and deliriogenic medicines (anticholinergics, metoclopramide, opioids).
3. Environment: a single quiet room, consistent staff, one-to-one nursing, an enclosed or low-floor bed in place of bed rails, remove the cannula unless it is essential, a structured day-night routine with daylight and activity by day, and limit visitors to one or two familiar people at a time. Allow supervised wandering in a secure area.
4. Behavioural approach: short simple sentences, do not argue with his beliefs, redirect, avoid crowding him during care; staff education and debriefing after the assault.
5. Medicines only if the above is not enough and risk is high: propranolol (for example 10-20 mg twice daily, titrated to heart rate and blood pressure) has the best evidence after brain injury; alternatives are valproate or carbamazepine, or low-dose quetiapine at night. Avoid routine haloperidol and benzodiazepines, which may slow cognitive recovery and prolong confusion. Review daily and taper when he emerges.
6. Legal and ethical: he lacks capacity during post-traumatic amnesia, so involve his medical treatment decision maker (Victoria) and follow the health service's restrictive practice policy, with clear documentation and incident reporting.
At week 6 he reports right hip pain. Examination shows a warm, mildly swollen right thigh with right hip flexion limited to 80 degrees. Serum alkaline phosphatase is mildly raised.
(d) Outline your differential diagnosis, investigations and management. 4 marks
Show the rubric and model answer
- Leading diagnosis heterotopic ossification (hip is the commonest site after brain injury; risk factors: severe injury, long coma, spasticity, immobility, fractures) (1)
- Differentials that must be excluded: deep vein thrombosis, occult fracture, septic arthritis or cellulitis (1)
- Investigations: Doppler ultrasound for deep vein thrombosis; triple-phase bone scan is the most sensitive early test; plain X-ray only positive after about 3-6 weeks; computed tomography for surgical planning; alkaline phosphatase and C-reactive protein non-specific (1)
- Management: non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug (for example indomethacin or celecoxib) after discussion with neurosurgery given contusions; gentle pain-free range of motion; analgesia; positioning (1)
- Surgical excision only if it causes significant functional limitation, once mature, followed by prophylaxis (non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug or single-fraction radiotherapy) (1)
Differential diagnosis:
- Heterotopic ossification is the most likely: hip is the commonest site after brain injury, and he has risk factors (severe injury, prolonged coma, immobility, agitation, fracture).
- Deep vein thrombosis must be excluded first, as it presents similarly and is dangerous.
- Others: occult fracture (from a fall during agitation), septic arthritis, cellulitis.
Investigations:
- Doppler ultrasound of the leg.
- Triple-phase bone scan is the most sensitive early test; plain X-ray only becomes positive about 3-6 weeks after onset; ultrasound may show early changes.
- Alkaline phosphatase and C-reactive protein are supportive but non-specific.
- Computed tomography if surgery is later considered.
Management:
- A non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug such as indomethacin or celecoxib for several weeks, after checking with neurosurgery that the contusions and subdural are stable, with gastric protection and renal monitoring.
- Gentle, pain-free active-assisted range of motion to maintain movement; avoid forceful stretching.
- Analgesia, positioning and seating review.
- Refer for surgical excision only if a mature lesion causes significant functional limitation (sitting, hygiene, walking), with post-operative prophylaxis by non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug or single-fraction radiotherapy.
By week 10 Liam has emerged from post-traumatic amnesia (duration 41 days). He is walking independently on the ward. At the family meeting his partner asks when he can drive again and go back to his apprenticeship.
(e) Discuss how you would address return to driving and return to work at this family meeting. 5 marks
Show the rubric and model answer
- Honest prognosis framed by post-traumatic amnesia of 41 days (extremely severe): likely persisting cognitive and behavioural impairment, recovery continues over 1-2 years, uncertainty acknowledged (1)
- Driving: must not drive now; Austroads "Assessing Fitness to Drive" applies; licence decision rests with VicRoads; fitness depends on cognition, insight, vision, physical function and seizures (1)
- Process: neuropsychological assessment, then occupational therapy driver assessment (off-road and on-road); possible conditional licence; patient obliged to notify licensing authority and doctor may report if public safety at risk (1)
- Work: an apprentice electrician is safety-critical (live electrical work, heights, anosmia); graded return only after neuropsychological assessment (1)
- Vocational rehabilitation funded by the Transport Accident Commission, workplace assessment, liaison with employer and registered training organisation, alternative duties or retraining if needed (1)
- Meeting process: Liam present and included, partner as support, written plan, address partner stress, relationship and carer support, follow up (1)
I would hold the meeting with Liam present, his partner, and the key team members, check what they already understand, and agree what they want from the meeting.
Prognosis framing: post-traumatic amnesia of 41 days puts this in the extremely severe range. Most people keep improving for one to two years, but persisting problems with memory, attention, planning and behaviour are likely, and he may not notice them himself. I would give realistic hope without promising timeframes.
Driving:
- He must not drive now. Fitness is judged under the Austroads "Assessing Fitness to Drive" standards, considering cognition, insight, impulsivity, vision, physical function and seizure risk; the licensing decision belongs to VicRoads.
- The steps are neuropsychological assessment, then a specialist occupational therapy driver assessment (off-road then on-road). The outcome may be an unconditional licence, a conditional licence (for example local area, daylight only), or not fit for now.
- Liam has a legal duty to tell VicRoads; I would explain that I may notify the authority if he drives against advice and puts the public at risk.
Work:
- His apprenticeship is safety-critical: live electrical work, ladders and heights, and possible anosmia (he may not smell burning). Any return must follow neuropsychological assessment and be graded, starting with non-safety-critical tasks and short hours.
- The Transport Accident Commission funds vocational rehabilitation: a workplace assessment, liaison with his employer and training provider, a graded plan, and alternative duties or retraining if electrical work is not safe.
I would also ask about his partner's own coping, offer carer and relationship support, give a written summary, and set a date to review.
Where candidates lose marks here
- Describing the CT as "bleeding in the brain" without naming contusions, diffuse axonal injury and the regions affected, or failing to link the anatomy to the expected deficits.
- Getting the Westmead emergence rule wrong (it is 12/12 on three consecutive days, with post-traumatic amnesia ending on the first of the three).
- Reaching straight for haloperidol or benzodiazepines for agitation without first treating pain, retention, constipation and the environment.
- Diagnosing heterotopic ossification without excluding deep vein thrombosis, or relying on a plain X-ray in the first weeks.
- Giving a fixed driving date instead of describing the Austroads process and the licensing authority role; using abbreviations such as PTA, HO or TAC without writing them out.
Original content written for Fellowship Ready, for exam preparation only, not clinical advice. Not affiliated with the RACP or the AFRM.