Breathing systems, carbon dioxide absorption and scavenging
What a breathing system must do, the classification of breathing systems, the Mapleson systems and how fresh gas flow prevents rebreathing in each, the circle system and the chemistry and hazards of carbon dioxide absorbents, low-flow anaesthesia, self-inflating resuscitation bags, and the hazards of waste anaesthetic gas and how it is scavenged.
By the end of this page you should be able to
- State the properties of an ideal breathing system and classify breathing systems.
- Describe the Mapleson A, D and F systems and explain the fresh gas flow needed to prevent rebreathing in spontaneous and controlled ventilation.
- Describe the circle system, its components and its advantages and disadvantages.
- Explain the chemistry of soda lime and the hazards of carbon dioxide absorbents.
- Outline the hazards of waste anaesthetic gas and describe active and passive scavenging.
What a breathing system does
A breathing system delivers gas from the machine to the patient and removes exhaled carbon dioxide, either by washing it out with fresh gas flow or by chemical absorption. The ideal system has low dead space and low resistance (short, wide, smooth tubing with few connectors), is efficient in fresh gas use, conserves heat and moisture, is light, safe, easy to scavenge, and works for both spontaneous and controlled ventilation in patients of every size.
Systems are often described as open (no reservoir, no rebreathing: insufflation), semi-open, semi-closed (a reservoir, partial rebreathing possible, excess vented) and closed (fresh gas only replaces what the patient takes up, all exhaled gas is rebreathed after absorption). A more useful division is by function: systems that rely on fresh gas flow to remove carbon dioxide (the Mapleson systems) and those that absorb it (the circle).
The Mapleson systems
The Mapleson classification describes systems built from a reservoir bag, corrugated tubing, an adjustable pressure limiting (APL) valve and a fresh gas inlet, arranged in different orders. The key to each is where fresh gas, dead space gas and alveolar gas go during the expiratory pause.
Mapleson A (Magill; Lack is the coaxial version): fresh gas enters at the bag end and the APL valve is at the patient end. During spontaneous breathing, the first exhaled gas (dead space gas, without carbon dioxide) passes back along the tubing; once the bag fills, alveolar gas vents through the valve at the patient end, and in the pause fresh gas pushes any alveolar gas left in the tubing out of the valve. It is therefore the most efficient system for spontaneous ventilation, needing a fresh gas flow of about the alveolar minute ventilation (roughly 70 mL/kg/min). It is inefficient for controlled ventilation, because squeezing the bag opens the valve during inspiration and alveolar gas is pushed back towards the patient; it then needs about three times minute ventilation.
Mapleson D (Bain is the coaxial version, with fresh gas delivered through the inner tube to the patient end): fresh gas enters at the patient end and the valve is at the bag end. During controlled ventilation, fresh gas fills the tubing in the expiratory pause and pushes exhaled gas towards the bag and valve, so it is efficient for controlled ventilation (fresh gas flow around 70 mL/kg/min gives near normocapnia) and inefficient for spontaneous breathing (needing about two to three times minute ventilation). A disconnected or kinked inner tube in a Bain turns the whole outer tube into dead space; the Pethick test checks it.
Mapleson E (Ayre's T-piece) and Mapleson F (Jackson-Rees modification, with an open-tailed bag) have very low resistance and no valve, so they suit small children; the bag shows spontaneous breathing and allows controlled ventilation. They need high fresh gas flows (about two to three times minute ventilation) and are harder to scavenge. Mapleson B and C have the valve and fresh gas inlet both at the patient end; C (the Waters circuit without an absorber) is used for transfer and resuscitation, and both are inefficient.
A mnemonic for efficiency: for spontaneous ventilation, A is best, then D, F, E, then C and B; for controlled ventilation, D, F and E are best, then B and C, and A is worst.
The circle system
The circle uses unidirectional valves so gas flows one way round: from the fresh gas inlet through the inspiratory valve and limb to the Y-piece, back through the expiratory limb and valve to the reservoir bag or ventilator and APL valve, then through the absorber and back to the inspiratory side. Exhaled gas is rebreathed after carbon dioxide is removed.
Advantages: economy, because fresh gas can be reduced to little more than the patient's uptake (low-flow and minimal-flow anaesthesia); conservation of heat and moisture; less pollution and lower environmental impact; and dead space only from the Y-piece to the patient. Disadvantages: bulk and complexity, more connections and potential leaks; valve sticking or incompetence causing rebreathing; resistance from valves and absorber; at low fresh gas flow, the inspired concentration differs from the dial setting and changes slowly (a long time constant), so agent and oxygen monitoring are essential; accumulation of gases such as nitrogen, methane, acetone, alcohol and carbon monoxide during long closed-system use; and absorbent hazards.
The position of components matters: the fresh gas inlet should be between the absorber and the inspiratory valve; the APL valve and bag on the expiratory side before the absorber, so that the gas vented is exhaled gas rich in carbon dioxide rather than fresh gas.
Carbon dioxide absorption
Soda lime is mostly calcium hydroxide, with small amounts of sodium hydroxide (and, in older formulations, potassium hydroxide) as activators, water, silica for hardness and an indicator dye (commonly ethyl violet) that changes colour as the pH falls. Granule size balances surface area for absorption against resistance to gas flow.
The reactions: carbon dioxide dissolves in the water in the granule to form carbonic acid; this reacts with sodium hydroxide to form sodium carbonate and water, releasing heat; sodium carbonate then reacts with calcium hydroxide to form calcium carbonate, regenerating sodium hydroxide. Overall, heat and water are produced, which warms and humidifies the circle gas. Exhaustion shows as rising inspired carbon dioxide on the capnogram, often before the colour change, and the dye can revert on standing, so capnography is the reliable sign.
Hazards: compound A from sevoflurane, formed with strong bases (sodium and potassium hydroxide) and favoured by low fresh gas flows and high absorber temperature; carbon monoxide from desflurane and, less so, isoflurane, when the absorbent has been dried out (for example by oxygen left flowing over a weekend); heat and, rarely, fire with dry strong-base absorbents and sevoflurane; dust; and channelling of gas through part of the canister. Newer absorbents without strong bases (calcium hydroxide with calcium chloride, or lithium hydroxide) greatly reduce compound A and carbon monoxide formation.
Resuscitation bags and scavenging
Self-inflating bags refill from room air and an oxygen reservoir through an inlet valve, with a non-rebreathing valve at the patient end, so they work without a gas supply. The oxygen fraction depends on oxygen flow and the reservoir; without a reservoir it is far lower. They do not show spontaneous breathing well, and some valves resist spontaneous breaths or allow little passive oxygen, so they are not ideal for preoxygenating a spontaneously breathing patient without a seal and adequate flow.
Waste anaesthetic gas leaks from circuits, masks, uncuffed tubes and exhaled breath in recovery. Long-term exposure to nitrous oxide and volatile agents has been associated with headache, fatigue and concerns about reproductive and haematological effects, and occupational exposure standards apply. Scavenging collects gas from the APL valve and ventilator exhaust. Passive systems use the patient's expiratory effort to push gas through wide tubing to the outside or into the room ventilation extract; they are simple but sensitive to wind and pressure changes. Active systems use a fan or pump to create a low negative pressure, with a receiving system (an open reservoir or a valved interface) that includes positive and negative pressure relief so that the patient's airway is never exposed to suction or obstruction. Scavenging connectors are a different size (30 mm) from breathing system connectors (22 and 15 mm) to prevent misconnection. Room air changes, low-flow technique, good mask fit and turning off gases before disconnection reduce exposure further.
Structuring the answer
- For any Mapleson system, draw it, then walk through inspiration, expiration and the expiratory pause, saying where alveolar gas goes.
- State the fresh gas flow needed for spontaneous and controlled ventilation, and why.
- For the circle, list components in order of gas flow and justify the position of the fresh gas inlet, APL valve and absorber.
- Give the soda lime reactions in words and say what is produced (heat and water).
Common traps
- Calling the Mapleson A efficient for controlled ventilation.
- Relying on the soda lime colour change rather than the capnogram.
- Assuming the inspired concentration in a circle equals the dial setting at low flow.
- Forgetting the Bain inner tube disconnection hazard.
- Designing scavenging without positive and negative pressure relief.
Where this meets anaesthesia
- Rising inspired carbon dioxide on the capnogram is the reliable sign of absorbent exhaustion or an incompetent valve.
- At low fresh gas flows in a circle system, the inspired agent concentration lags behind the dial setting.
Viva questions
Answer each one aloud, as you would to an examiner, before you open the model points.
- 1.
What are the properties of an ideal breathing system?
Show answer
- Low dead space and resistance; efficient use of fresh gas.
- Conserves heat and moisture; light, simple, robust.
- Suitable for spontaneous and controlled ventilation in all sizes of patient.
- Easy to scavenge, monitor and check; few connections.
- 2.
Describe the Mapleson A system during spontaneous ventilation.
Show answer
- Fresh gas at the bag end, APL valve at the patient end.
- Dead space gas returns along the tubing first; alveolar gas vents once the bag is full.
- Fresh gas flushes remaining alveolar gas out during the pause.
- Efficient with fresh gas flow about equal to alveolar minute ventilation.
- 3.
Why is the Mapleson A inefficient for controlled ventilation, and what would you use instead?
Show answer
- Squeezing the bag opens the valve during inspiration, venting fresh gas.
- Alveolar gas in the tubing is pushed back to the patient; rebreathing.
- Needs about three times minute ventilation.
- Mapleson D (Bain) or a circle system is efficient for controlled ventilation.
- 4.
Describe the Bain system and its main hazard.
Show answer
- Coaxial Mapleson D: fresh gas through the inner tube to the patient end, exhaled gas along the outer tube to bag and valve.
- Efficient for controlled ventilation; inefficient for spontaneous breathing.
- Inner tube disconnection or kinking makes the outer tube dead space, causing hypercapnia.
- Pethick test checks inner tube integrity.
- 5.
Why is the T-piece used in small children?
Show answer
- No valves, very low resistance and dead space.
- Open-tailed bag (Jackson-Rees) shows breathing and allows controlled ventilation.
- Needs high fresh gas flows; scavenging is more difficult.
- Light and simple.
- 6.
Describe the circle system and its advantages and disadvantages.
Show answer
- Unidirectional valves, absorber, reservoir bag, APL valve, fresh gas inlet between absorber and inspiratory valve.
- Advantages: economy, heat and moisture conservation, less pollution, dead space only from Y-piece.
- Disadvantages: complexity, leaks, valve failure, resistance, absorbent hazards.
- At low flow, inspired concentration lags the dial; monitoring is essential.
- 7.
What is soda lime and how does it absorb carbon dioxide?
Show answer
- Mainly calcium hydroxide with sodium hydroxide, water, silica and an indicator.
- Carbon dioxide forms carbonic acid, which reacts with sodium hydroxide to sodium carbonate, heat and water.
- Sodium carbonate reacts with calcium hydroxide to calcium carbonate, regenerating sodium hydroxide.
- Exhaustion shown by rising inspired carbon dioxide; colour change is less reliable.
- 8.
What are the hazards of carbon dioxide absorbents?
Show answer
- Compound A from sevoflurane with strong bases, more at low flow and high temperature.
- Carbon monoxide from desflurane and isoflurane with dried absorbent.
- Heat, rarely fire; dust; channelling.
- Reduced by absorbents without strong bases and by not leaving gas flowing on idle machines.
- 9.
How is waste anaesthetic gas scavenged?
Show answer
- Collected from the APL valve and ventilator exhaust through 30 mm connectors.
- Passive: expiratory effort drives gas out; simple but affected by external pressure.
- Active: fan creates low negative pressure; receiving system with positive and negative pressure relief protects the patient.
- Plus room ventilation, low-flow technique and good practice to limit exposure.
Practise this week
- Primary MCQs: measurement and equipment
- Primary MCQs: quality and safety
- Primary SAQs, marked part by part
- Primary vivas
Week 6 in the other subjects
- Physiology: Diffusion and oxygen transport
- Pharmacology: Respiratory drugs, antihistamines and anaphylaxis
- Procedural anatomy: Thoracic wall, pleura and lungs
Not affiliated with the Australian and New Zealand College of Anaesthetists (ANZCA). Notes are a revision aid, not a substitute for the curriculum or for clinical guidelines.