CICM Second Part Examination (written SAQs, hot cases, vivas) 2025.2 (August/October 2025): what the examiners said
Report released November 2025 · Summary checked
The headline
Candidates who answered exactly what was asked, for the patient in front of them, with a reason for each decision, passed; ABCD templates did not.
An independent plain-English summary. Fellowship Ready is not affiliated with or endorsed by the CICM. Read the original report on the CICM website. Read the full report.
Results and format
Results: Written 45/83 (54%). At orals, 50/64 (78%) passed the vivas and 24/64 (38%) passed both hot cases. Overall 43/102 (42%).
Format: Two written papers of 15 ten-mark SAQs (Angoff pass mark about 52%), then two hot cases and eight vivas in Brisbane.
What candidates did well
Structured answers that followed the glossary instruction words.
Answers tailored to the patient with a clear rationale.
Systematic approaches in the vivas.
Where marks were lost, and how to fix it
Biostatistics basics
What went wrong: Simple calculations such as relative risk reduction and number needed to treat were wrong or not shown.
How to fix it: Drill 2x2 table calculations until fast, and always show workings.
Linking co-existing problems
What went wrong: When two conditions coexisted, candidates did not explain how treating one affected the other.
How to fix it: For every multi-problem stem, write one line on each treatment's effect on the other condition.
Condition-specific management
What went wrong: Answers drifted to generic care, for example hypertension after adrenal surgery without phaeochromocytoma-specific reasoning.
How to fix it: Learn the one or two disease-specific steps that change management for each syllabus condition.
Anticoagulant reversal
What went wrong: In a bleeding patient on an anticoagulant, reversal was missed or deferred to other teams.
How to fix it: Know the specific reversal agent and dose for each anticoagulant and state it early.
Data interpretation
What went wrong: Acid-base and biochemistry were listed without workings or a system.
How to fix it: Use a fixed sequence (pH, primary process, compensation, gaps) and write the calculation.
Family communication
What went wrong: Communication was rushed or dismissive, with unrealistic reassurance and missed cues.
How to fix it: Practise breaking bad news with a framework: check understanding, give a warning shot, be honest, respond to emotion.
Advice for the next sitting
Do exactly the number of items requested; extras are not marked.
Give a reason for every management step.
Reverse anticoagulation explicitly in any bleeding scenario.
Original questions written to train the themes above (not questions from the exam). Answer each to see the explanation and why the other options are wrong.
Question 1 of 5Biostatistics basics
In a trial, 28-day mortality is 20% with usual care and 15% with a new treatment. What is the number needed to treat to prevent one death?
Pick an answer to see the explanation.
Fix what the examiners said
The same habits cost marks sitting after sitting. Each one has a short drill of questions from the Intensive care bank that test exactly that habit.