What the CICM examiners said
After each sitting the CICM publishes a public exam report on where candidates did well and where they lost marks. Here is each one in plain English: what went wrong, how to fix it, and five practice questions on the weak spots. Free, no sign-up.
2026.1 (March/May 2026) · released June 2026
Second Part Examination (written SAQs, hot cases, vivas) 2026.1 (March/May 2026): what the examiners said
Generic, template answers that ignored the specific patient and the exact instruction word were the main reason marks were lost.
2026.1 (February/April 2026) · released May 2026
First Part Examination (MCQ, SAQ, vivas) 2026.1 (February/April 2026): what the examiners said
The exam now rewards physiology and pharmacology applied to intensive care; answers that ignored the ICU and intravenous context lost marks.
2025.2 (August/October 2025) · released November 2025
Second Part Examination (written SAQs, hot cases, vivas) 2025.2 (August/October 2025): what the examiners said
Candidates who answered exactly what was asked, for the patient in front of them, with a reason for each decision, passed; ABCD templates did not.
2025.2 (August/October 2025) · released October 2025
First Part Examination (MCQ, SAQ, vivas) 2025.2 (August/October 2025): what the examiners said
MCQs were passed by most, but under half passed the SAQs because answers named effects without explaining the mechanism.
2025.1 (March/May 2025) · released June 2025
Second Part Examination (written SAQs, hot cases, vivas) 2025.1 (March/May 2025): what the examiners said
Shallow, generic answers without rationale failed, while structured answers that justified each decision for the specific scenario passed.
2025.1 (March/May 2025) · released May 2025
First Part Examination (MCQ, SAQ, vivas) 2025.1 (March/May 2025): what the examiners said
About half passed overall, with SAQ answers too shallow on receptor, transport and cellular mechanisms.
2024.2 (August/October 2024) · released November 2024
Second Part Examination (written SAQs, hot cases, vivas) 2024.2 (August/October 2024): what the examiners said
With an overall pass rate of 37%, the commonest failing was answering a different or more generic question than the one asked.
2024.2 (August/October 2024) · released October 2024
First Part Examination (MCQ, SAQ, vivas) 2024.2 (August/October 2024): what the examiners said
Candidates listed facts without explaining or applying them to intensive care, so structure, depth and breadth were the main gaps.
2024.1 (March/May 2024) · released June 2024
Second Part Examination (written SAQs, hot cases, vivas) 2024.1 (March/May 2024): what the examiners said
Marks were lost through missing specifics: drug doses, targets, units and the exact patient group named in the stem.
2024.1 (March/May 2024) · released May 2024
First Part Examination (MCQ, SAQ, vivas) 2024.1 (March/May 2024): what the examiners said
Integrating physiology was the main gap: some topics such as fibrinolysis, innate immunity and afterload had very low SAQ pass rates.
2023.2 (August/October 2023) · released November 2023
Second Part Examination (written SAQs, hot cases, vivas) 2023.2 (August/October 2023): what the examiners said
Data interpretation was a strength, but generic answers, unasked-for resuscitation detail and unsafe airway plans cost candidates.
2023.2 (August/October 2023) · released October 2023
First Part Examination (MCQ, SAQ, vivas) 2023.2 (August/October 2023): what the examiners said
Less than half passed the written, with very low pass rates on questions that needed explanation of mechanisms rather than recall.
Fix what the examiners said
The same habits cost marks sitting after sitting. Each one has a short drill of questions from the Intensive care bank that test exactly that habit.
Answering a neighbouring question 15 questions
Giving a good answer to a question that was not asked.
Not specific enough 15 questions
Naming the right idea without the dose, interval, threshold or number that earns the mark.
Deferring the decision 15 questions
Waiting, reviewing later or handing it on when the case needs you to act now.
Poor structure and priorities 15 questions
Knowing all the steps but not which comes first.
Missing the detail in the stem 15 questions
Skipping the age, medicine, allergy or setting that changes the answer.
Running out of time 15 questions
Spending too long on early questions and rushing or skipping the rest.
An independent plain-English summary. Fellowship Ready is not affiliated with or endorsed by the CICM. Read the original report on the CICM website.
Every specialty: all examiner report summaries →