CICM examiner reports · 2024.2 (August/October 2024) CICM Second Part Examination (written SAQs, hot cases, vivas) 2024.2 (August/October 2024): what the examiners said Report released November 2024 · Summary checked 18 November 2026
The headline
With an overall pass rate of 37%, the commonest failing was answering a different or more generic question than the one asked.
An independent plain-English summary. Fellowship Ready is not affiliated with or endorsed by the CICM. Read the original report on the CICM website. Read the full report .
Results What went wrong Advice Practice questions Results and format Results: Written 53/108 (49%). Hot case section 43/70 (61%), both cases 24/70 (34%). Vivas 51/70 (73%). Overall 46/125 (37%).
Format: Two written papers of 15 SAQs, 300 marks total (Angoff pass mark about 52%), then two hot cases and eight vivas in Sydney.
What candidates did well Structured, patient-specific management with clear rationale. Some laboratory and blood questions were well handled. Post-cardiac surgery hypotension was generally well structured. Where marks were lost, and how to fix it Fluid responsiveness What went wrong: Static measures such as central venous pressure were offered instead of dynamic tests.
How to fix it: Learn the dynamic tests, their thresholds and the conditions that invalidate them.
Safe sodium correction What went wrong: Hyponatraemia plans lacked safe correction limits and specific steps.
How to fix it: Memorise the daily correction limit and what to do if it is exceeded.
Extracorporeal support What went wrong: Venovenous ECMO was confused with venoarterial ECMO and contraindications were omitted.
How to fix it: Tabulate VV versus VA ECMO: indications, circuit, what each supports and key contraindications.
Bacteraemia work-up What went wrong: Staphylococcus aureus bacteraemia was treated as a simple positive culture without searching for other foci.
How to fix it: Learn the bundle of care for S. aureus bacteraemia: repeat cultures, echocardiography, source control, specialist input.
Device physiology What went wrong: Intra-aortic balloon pump traces were misread.
How to fix it: Practise identifying timing errors on IABP waveforms and their haemodynamic consequences.
Advice for the next sitting Weigh time by marks; do not overwrite low-mark parts. Use dynamic, not static, measures when discussing fluid responsiveness. Read relevant CICM documents such as the one on rapid response systems. Practise bedside procedures such as bronchoscopy before the viva. Read the full report: CICM Second Part Examination Report 2024.2 ↗
Practise the weak spots: 5 questions Original questions written to train the themes above (not questions from the exam). Answer each to see the explanation and why the other options are wrong.
Question 1 of 5 Fluid responsiveness
A spontaneously breathing patient in atrial fibrillation is hypotensive after a laparotomy. Which test best predicts fluid responsiveness? A Passive leg raise with real-time VTI measurement B Pulse pressure variation over 13% C Central venous pressure below 8 mmHg D Inferior vena cava diameter under 2 cm
Pick an answer to see the explanation. Next question →
Question 1 of 5 · Fluid responsiveness
A spontaneously breathing patient in atrial fibrillation is hypotensive after a laparotomy. Which test best predicts fluid responsiveness?
Passive leg raise with real-time VTI measurement Pulse pressure variation over 13% Central venous pressure below 8 mmHg Inferior vena cava diameter under 2 cm Show the answer A. Passive leg raise with real-time VTI measurement
Passive leg raising is a reversible self-bolus that remains valid in spontaneous breathing and arrhythmia, provided cardiac output (for example LVOT VTI on echo) is measured in real time. References: CICM Second Part curriculum (haemodynamic monitoring); Oh's Intensive Care Manual.
Why not B: Pulse pressure variation is invalid in spontaneous breathing and arrhythmia. Why not C: CVP is a static measure that predicts fluid responsiveness poorly. Why not D: A single IVC diameter is a static measure and unreliable in spontaneous breathing. Question 2 of 5 · Safe sodium correction
A malnourished patient with alcohol use disorder has a serum sodium of 109 mmol/L and mild confusion; the hyponatraemia is chronic. What is the maximum safe correction in the first 24 hours?
4 mmol/L 8 mmol/L 15 mmol/L 20 mmol/L Show the answer B. 8 mmol/L
Patients at high risk of osmotic demyelination (alcohol misuse, malnutrition, hypokalaemia, liver disease, sodium below 105-110) should be corrected by no more than 8 mmol/L in 24 hours. If overcorrection occurs, re-lowering with water and desmopressin is considered. References: Therapeutic Guidelines (eTG) Endocrinology: hyponatraemia; European clinical practice guideline on hyponatraemia.
Why not A: 4-6 mmol/L is a reasonable aim, not the ceiling. Why not C: 15 mmol/L exceeds safe limits and risks osmotic demyelination. Why not D: 20 mmol/L is unsafe in chronic hyponatraemia. Question 3 of 5 · Extracorporeal support
Which patient most clearly needs venoarterial rather than venovenous ECMO?
Severe ARDS with PaO2/FiO2 of 60 and normal ventricular function Bridge to lung transplant for pulmonary fibrosis with preserved cardiac function Status asthmaticus with refractory hypercapnia Refractory cardiogenic shock after myocardial infarction despite two inotropes Show the answer D. Refractory cardiogenic shock after myocardial infarction despite two inotropes
VV-ECMO supports gas exchange only and relies on the patient's own cardiac output. Refractory cardiogenic shock needs circulatory support, which VA-ECMO provides. References: Extracorporeal Life Support Organization (ELSO) guidelines; ANZICS / CICM Second Part curriculum (extracorporeal support).
Why not A: Isolated respiratory failure with good cardiac function is the VV-ECMO indication. Why not B: Preserved cardiac function means VV support is usually sufficient. Why not C: Hypercapnic respiratory failure is treated with VV support or CO2 removal. Question 4 of 5 · Bacteraemia work-up
A ventilated patient grows methicillin-sensitive Staphylococcus aureus from two blood culture sets. Which action is essential beyond starting IV flucloxacillin?
Add rifampicin routinely Switch to oral therapy once afebrile Repeat blood cultures and echocardiography Stop antibiotics once the central line is removed Show the answer C. Repeat blood cultures and echocardiography
S. aureus bacteraemia needs repeat cultures to document clearance, echocardiography (transoesophageal if high risk) to exclude endocarditis, a search for metastatic foci and infectious diseases input. Duration depends on whether it is complicated. References: Therapeutic Guidelines (eTG) Antibiotic: Staphylococcus aureus bacteraemia; Australasian Society for Infectious Diseases.
Why not A: Routine adjunctive rifampicin has not improved outcomes (ARREST trial). Why not B: Early oral switch is not standard before clearance and assessment for complicated infection. Why not D: Line removal is source control, but a minimum IV course is still required. Question 5 of 5 · Device physiology
On an intra-aortic balloon pump trace, the balloon deflates late, during early systole. What is the main consequence?
Improved coronary perfusion Higher afterload and oxygen demand Lower left ventricular afterload Retrograde coronary and carotid flow Show the answer B. Higher afterload and oxygen demand
Late deflation means the ventricle ejects against a still-inflated balloon, raising afterload and oxygen demand, which defeats the device's purpose. Early deflation instead causes retrograde coronary and carotid flow. References: CICM Second Part curriculum (mechanical circulatory support); Oh's Intensive Care Manual.
Why not A: Coronary perfusion is augmented by correctly timed inflation in diastole, not by late deflation. Why not C: Correctly timed deflation lowers afterload; late deflation raises it. Why not D: Retrograde flow is a feature of early, not late, deflation. Create a free account to keep going →
Fix what the examiners said The same habits cost marks sitting after sitting. Each one has a short drill of questions from the Intensive care bank that test exactly that habit.
Practise the rest free. CICM-style questions on every area the examiners keep flagging, each marked with a reason for every option. Free account, no card.
Other CICM sittings 2026.1 (March/May 2026) · released June 2026
Second Part Examination (written SAQs, hot cases, vivas) 2026.1 (March/May 2026): what the examiners said
Generic, template answers that ignored the specific patient and the exact instruction word were the main reason marks were lost.
2026.1 (February/April 2026) · released May 2026
First Part Examination (MCQ, SAQ, vivas) 2026.1 (February/April 2026): what the examiners said
The exam now rewards physiology and pharmacology applied to intensive care; answers that ignored the ICU and intravenous context lost marks.
2025.2 (August/October 2025) · released November 2025
Second Part Examination (written SAQs, hot cases, vivas) 2025.2 (August/October 2025): what the examiners said
Candidates who answered exactly what was asked, for the patient in front of them, with a reason for each decision, passed; ABCD templates did not.
All CICM examiner reports →
Source
CICM Second Part Examination Report 2024.2 (CICM, November 2024)
An independent plain-English summary. Fellowship Ready is not affiliated with or endorsed by the CICM. Read the original report on the CICM website. Summaries are in our own words; formats and pass rules change, so always check the college's current information. Not affiliated with the CICM.