CICM examiner reports · 2026.1 (March/May 2026) CICM Second Part Examination (written SAQs, hot cases, vivas) 2026.1 (March/May 2026): what the examiners said Report released June 2026 · Summary checked 18 November 2026
The headline
Generic, template answers that ignored the specific patient and the exact instruction word were the main reason marks were lost.
An independent plain-English summary. Fellowship Ready is not affiliated with or endorsed by the CICM. Read the original report on the CICM website. Read the full report .
Results What went wrong Advice Practice questions Results and format Results: Written 47/72 (65%) passed. Of 63 candidates at the orals, 40 passed the vivas (63%) and 40 passed overall (63%); only 25/63 (40%) passed both hot cases.
Format: Two written papers of 15 ten-mark SAQs (Angoff pass mark about 52%), then two hot cases and eight vivas over two days.
What candidates did well Sound core knowledge on common topics such as acid-base interpretation and ventilator waveforms. Tables used well in compare-and-contrast questions. Answers organised under history, examination and investigation headings scored better. Respectful conduct and a structured approach at the bedside were rewarded. Where marks were lost, and how to fix it Generic template answers What went wrong: Pro-forma resuscitation or ABCD answers were written when the question asked about one specific patient or problem, earning few marks.
How to fix it: Practise rewriting answers so every line names the patient's own condition, drug or finding; strike out anything that would fit any patient.
Drill this habit: not specific enough, 15 questions →
Not following the instruction word What went wrong: Candidates listed when asked to discuss or justify, or wrote management when asked about assessment.
How to fix it: Learn the CICM glossary of terms and underline the verb before writing; time yourself answering the same stem with list, outline and discuss.
Drill this habit: answering a neighbouring question, 15 questions →
Imprecise data interpretation What went wrong: Results were listed rather than interpreted, and terms were too vague to score (for example metabolic acidosis without stating the anion gap type).
How to fix it: Always state the pattern and its significance: calculate gaps, classify the disorder and give the likely cause.
Drill this habit: not specific enough, 15 questions →
Research and statistics literacy What went wrong: Forest plots were misread for direction of effect, and association was confused with causation.
How to fix it: Practise reading confidence intervals against the line of no effect and state what a study design can and cannot show.
Practical device knowledge What went wrong: Temporary epicardial pacing settings such as sensitivity were poorly understood at the viva.
How to fix it: Spend time at the bedside with pacing boxes after cardiac surgery and rehearse troubleshooting out loud.
Hot case examination and synthesis What went wrong: Key signs were missed or reported when absent, examinations were unfocused, and plans were hesitant.
How to fix it: Do timed focused examinations daily with a consultant and present a prioritised synthesis within two minutes.
Advice for the next sitting Read the verb and the mark allocation of every part before writing. Tailor every point to the stem; delete generic resuscitation unless it is asked for. Interpret data rather than transcribing it, and be specific with drug names and doses. Practise hot cases and vivas with senior colleagues and seek performance coaching if nerves affect you. Read the full report: CICM Second Part Examination Report 2026.1 ↗
Practise the weak spots: 5 questions Original questions written to train the themes above (not questions from the exam). Answer each to see the explanation and why the other options are wrong.
Question 1 of 5 Research and statistics literacy
A meta-analysis comparing a new sedation strategy with usual care reports a pooled risk ratio for 90-day mortality of 0.90 (95% confidence interval 0.78 to 1.04). Which interpretation is correct? A The strategy significantly reduces mortality by about 10% B No statistically significant difference is shown C The strategy causes a small increase in mortality D The strategy is proven equivalent to usual care
Pick an answer to see the explanation. Next question →
Question 1 of 5 · Research and statistics literacy
A meta-analysis comparing a new sedation strategy with usual care reports a pooled risk ratio for 90-day mortality of 0.90 (95% confidence interval 0.78 to 1.04). Which interpretation is correct?
The strategy significantly reduces mortality by about 10% No statistically significant difference is shown The strategy causes a small increase in mortality The strategy is proven equivalent to usual care Show the answer B. No statistically significant difference is shown
The confidence interval crosses 1.0 (the line of no effect), so the result is compatible with benefit, no effect or small harm and is not statistically significant. Absence of significance is not proof of equivalence, which needs a pre-specified equivalence margin. References: CICM Second Part curriculum (research and evidence appraisal); Cochrane Handbook for Systematic Reviews of Interventions.
Why not A: The point estimate suggests a 10% relative reduction, but the interval includes 1.0 so a reduction is not demonstrated. Why not C: A risk ratio below 1 favours the intervention; it does not indicate harm. Why not D: Equivalence requires a pre-defined margin and an interval lying within it; a non-significant result does not establish it. Question 2 of 5 · Imprecise data interpretation
A patient with a high-output ileostomy has: Na 138 mmol/L, Cl 116 mmol/L, HCO3 14 mmol/L, albumin 38 g/L, pH 7.24, PaCO2 30 mmHg. Which description earns full credit?
Normal anion gap metabolic acidosis from bicarbonate loss Metabolic acidosis with appropriate respiratory compensation High anion gap metabolic acidosis from lactate accumulation Mixed metabolic acidosis and primary respiratory acidosis Show the answer A. Normal anion gap metabolic acidosis from bicarbonate loss
Anion gap = 138 - (116 + 14) = 8, which is normal with a normal albumin. Expected PaCO2 by Winter's formula is 1.5 x 14 + 8 = 29 +/- 2 mmHg, so compensation is appropriate. Naming the gap type and the cause is what makes the answer specific. References: CICM Second Part curriculum (acid-base); Oh's Intensive Care Manual.
Why not B: Correct but incomplete: it does not state the anion gap type or cause, which is the level of detail examiners reward. Why not C: The anion gap is 8, which is not raised. Why not D: Measured PaCO2 matches the predicted value, so there is no primary respiratory acidosis. Question 3 of 5 · Imprecise data interpretation
Lung function in a breathless 64-year-old shows FEV1 58% predicted, FVC 55% predicted, FEV1/FVC 0.84, TLC 61% predicted and DLCO 42% predicted. Which interpretation fits best?
Normal spirometry with isolated reduced gas transfer Obstructive defect with gas trapping and hyperinflation Restrictive defect from chest wall disease with preserved gas transfer Restriction with reduced gas transfer (parenchymal) Show the answer D. Restriction with reduced gas transfer (parenchymal)
A preserved or high FEV1/FVC ratio with a low TLC confirms restriction; a markedly reduced DLCO points to a parenchymal cause such as interstitial lung disease rather than an extraparenchymal one. References: Thoracic Society of Australia and New Zealand (TSANZ) / ANZSRS lung function interpretation guidance; Oh's Intensive Care Manual.
Why not A: FEV1, FVC and TLC are all reduced, so spirometry is not normal. Why not B: Obstruction requires a reduced FEV1/FVC ratio; here it is 0.84. Why not C: Chest wall or neuromuscular restriction usually preserves gas transfer when corrected for volume; DLCO here is 42%. Question 4 of 5 · Practical device knowledge
On day 1 after valve surgery, a patient is paced VVI via epicardial wires at 70/min. The monitor shows the patient's own QRS complexes at 80/min with pacing spikes falling on T waves. What is the most appropriate adjustment?
Increase the ventricular output (mA) Increase the pacing rate to 100/min Lower the sensitivity value (mV) Switch to asynchronous VOO mode Show the answer C. Lower the sensitivity value (mV)
Spikes despite intrinsic beats indicate undersensing. Lowering the sensitivity number (for example from 5 mV to 2 mV) makes the box more sensitive so it inhibits appropriately and avoids R-on-T. References: CICM Second Part curriculum (cardiothoracic intensive care); Oh's Intensive Care Manual (cardiac pacing).
Why not A: Output affects capture, not sensing; raising it would make inappropriate spikes more likely to capture on the T wave. Why not B: Overdrive pacing is not the fix for undersensing and adds myocardial oxygen demand. Why not D: Asynchronous pacing ignores intrinsic beats and increases the R-on-T risk. Question 5 of 5 · Generic template answers
A 30-year-old returned from Papua New Guinea 10 days ago with fever, jaundice, confusion and 6% Plasmodium falciparum parasitaemia. What is the first-line antimalarial in Australia?
Oral artemether-lumefantrine Intravenous artesunate Oral chloroquine Intravenous quinine as first line Show the answer B. Intravenous artesunate
Severe falciparum malaria (impaired consciousness, jaundice, parasitaemia over 5%) is treated with IV artesunate, followed by a full oral course once improving. Monitor glucose regularly, as hypoglycaemia is a recognised complication of severe malaria. References: Therapeutic Guidelines (eTG) Antibiotic: malaria; Australasian Society for Infectious Diseases malaria guidance.
Why not A: Oral therapy is for uncomplicated malaria and is used to complete treatment after IV artesunate. Why not C: Falciparum malaria from PNG is chloroquine resistant and this is severe disease. Why not D: Quinine is a fallback only when artesunate is not available and causes hypoglycaemia and QT prolongation. Create a free account to keep going →
Fix what the examiners said The same habits cost marks sitting after sitting. Each one has a short drill of questions from the Intensive care bank that test exactly that habit.
Practise the rest free. CICM-style questions on every area the examiners keep flagging, each marked with a reason for every option. Free account, no card.
Other CICM sittings 2026.1 (February/April 2026) · released May 2026
First Part Examination (MCQ, SAQ, vivas) 2026.1 (February/April 2026): what the examiners said
The exam now rewards physiology and pharmacology applied to intensive care; answers that ignored the ICU and intravenous context lost marks.
2025.2 (August/October 2025) · released November 2025
Second Part Examination (written SAQs, hot cases, vivas) 2025.2 (August/October 2025): what the examiners said
Candidates who answered exactly what was asked, for the patient in front of them, with a reason for each decision, passed; ABCD templates did not.
2025.2 (August/October 2025) · released October 2025
First Part Examination (MCQ, SAQ, vivas) 2025.2 (August/October 2025): what the examiners said
MCQs were passed by most, but under half passed the SAQs because answers named effects without explaining the mechanism.
All CICM examiner reports →
Source
CICM Second Part Examination Report 2026.1 (CICM, June 2026)
An independent plain-English summary. Fellowship Ready is not affiliated with or endorsed by the CICM. Read the original report on the CICM website. Summaries are in our own words; formats and pass rules change, so always check the college's current information. Not affiliated with the CICM.