CICM First Part Examination (MCQ, SAQ, vivas) 2024.1 (March/May 2024): what the examiners said
Report released May 2024 · Summary checked
The headline
Integrating physiology was the main gap: some topics such as fibrinolysis, innate immunity and afterload had very low SAQ pass rates.
An independent plain-English summary. Fellowship Ready is not affiliated with or endorsed by the CICM. Read the original report on the CICM website. Read the full report.
Results and format
Results: 89 sat the written; 53 invited to vivas. MCQ pass 96%. 52 passed the First Part overall.
Format: Two 2.5-hour written papers, each with 50 MCQs and 10 SAQs; candidates passing both MCQ and SAQ components proceed to eight 10-minute cross-table vivas.
What candidates did well
Structured answers using the headings provided.
Renal replacement therapy and heat regulation were relatively well answered.
Sinoatrial node physiology was generally known.
Where marks were lost, and how to fix it
Integrated cardiovascular physiology
What went wrong: The left ventricle's response to a sudden afterload rise was not linked to Frank-Starling, the Anrep effect or oxygen demand.
How to fix it: Explain each cardiovascular perturbation as a sequence of compensations over time.
Haemostasis and fibrinolysis
What went wrong: Fibrinolysis was not integrated with coagulation and alteplase was not compared with endogenous t-PA.
How to fix it: Draw coagulation and fibrinolysis together, including regulators such as PAI-1.
Vascular access anatomy
What went wrong: Femoral anatomy was unstructured and drifted into technique.
How to fix it: Learn the femoral triangle boundaries and the order of structures before discussing technique.
Opioid pharmacokinetics
What went wrong: Pharmacokinetic features were not linked to context-sensitive half-time.
How to fix it: Compare fentanyl and remifentanil by clearance, distribution and resulting offset.
Anticoagulant comparison
What went wrong: Differences between unfractionated heparin and enoxaparin were not taken to practical implications.
How to fix it: End every comparison with monitoring, reversal and use in renal failure.
Monitoring devices
What went wrong: EVD and fibreoptic ICP monitors were poorly compared for drift, calibration and complications.
How to fix it: Tabulate each monitor's mechanism, zeroing, drift and risks.
Advice for the next sitting
Attempt every question; all carry equal marks.
Explain diagrams rather than letting them stand alone.
List functions, not just components, in immunology answers.
Original questions written to train the themes above (not questions from the exam). Answer each to see the explanation and why the other options are wrong.
Question 1 of 5Vascular access anatomy
Just below the inguinal ligament, what is the order of structures from lateral to medial?
Pick an answer to see the explanation.
Fix what the examiners said
The same habits cost marks sitting after sitting. Each one has a short drill of questions from the Intensive care bank that test exactly that habit.