CICM Second Part Examination (written SAQs, hot cases, vivas) 2023.2 (August/October 2023): what the examiners said
Report released November 2023 · Summary checked
The headline
Data interpretation was a strength, but generic answers, unasked-for resuscitation detail and unsafe airway plans cost candidates.
An independent plain-English summary. Fellowship Ready is not affiliated with or endorsed by the CICM. Read the original report on the CICM website. Read the full report.
Results and format
Results: Written 47/81 (58%). Hot case section 45/58 (78%), both cases 17/58 (29%). Vivas 48/58 (83%). Overall 40/92 (43%).
Format: Two written papers of 15 SAQs (Angoff pass mark 52.6%), then two hot cases and eight vivas in Melbourne and Adelaide.
What candidates did well
Blood gas and biochemistry interpretation was of a high standard.
Coagulation and warfarin-related questions were well answered.
Post-intensive care syndrome and post-cardiac surgery ECG changes were well known.
Where marks were lost, and how to fix it
Corrections in acid-base
What went wrong: The anion gap was not corrected for low albumin, hiding a raised gap.
How to fix it: Always correct the anion gap for albumin in ICU patients.
Infection specifics
What went wrong: Microbiology was vague ('M/C/S'), transmission routes were wrong and drug choices poorly listed.
How to fix it: For each key ICU pathogen, learn transmission, precautions, the diagnostic test and first-line treatment.
Drug toxicity syndromes
What went wrong: Knowledge of propofol infusion syndrome was limited and investigations lacked expected abnormalities.
How to fix it: For each sedative toxicity, learn risk factors and the expected test findings.
Airway rescue
What went wrong: Candidates persisted with failing techniques and had no adequate front-of-neck access plan.
How to fix it: Rehearse the Vortex approach and scalpel-bougie-tube cricothyroidotomy until automatic.
Unasked content
What went wrong: Resuscitation detail and aetiology were written when only definitive management was asked.
How to fix it: Write only to the instruction; unasked content earns no marks and costs time.
Original questions written to train the themes above (not questions from the exam). Answer each to see the explanation and why the other options are wrong.
Question 1 of 5Corrections in acid-base
An ICU patient has Na 136, Cl 104, HCO3 20 mmol/L and albumin 20 g/L. What is the albumin-corrected anion gap (normal albumin 40 g/L)?
Pick an answer to see the explanation.
Fix what the examiners said
The same habits cost marks sitting after sitting. Each one has a short drill of questions from the Intensive care bank that test exactly that habit.