CICM Second Part Examination (written SAQs, hot cases, vivas) 2025.1 (March/May 2025): what the examiners said
Report released June 2025 · Summary checked
The headline
Shallow, generic answers without rationale failed, while structured answers that justified each decision for the specific scenario passed.
An independent plain-English summary. Fellowship Ready is not affiliated with or endorsed by the CICM. Read the original report on the CICM website. Read the full report.
Results and format
Results: Written: 41/62 invited to orals (66%). Hot case section 35/56 (63%), both cases 24/56 (43%). Vivas 46/56 (82%). Overall 43/77 (56%).
Format: Two written papers of 15 SAQs (Angoff pass mark 48.6%), then two hot cases and eight vivas in Melbourne.
What candidates did well
Structured answers that addressed every part of the question.
Stating the rationale for decisions.
Early mobilisation was generally well answered.
Where marks were lost, and how to fix it
Odds versus risk
What went wrong: Candidates confused odds with risk and could not show statistical calculations.
How to fix it: Practise converting between risk and odds from a 2x2 table and state which measure a study design reports.
Pregnancy physiology in data
What went wrong: Normal pregnancy blood gas values were misread and A-a gradient calculations contained errors.
How to fix it: Learn pregnancy reference ranges (lower PaCO2 and bicarbonate) and practise the alveolar gas equation.
Antimicrobial pharmacokinetics
What went wrong: Dosing in renal failure and renal replacement therapy was reduced to 'reduce the dose' without killing characteristics or targets.
How to fix it: For each antibiotic class, know whether killing is time- or concentration-dependent and how that changes dosing.
Coagulation test interpretation
What went wrong: Normal results were misinterpreted and the mixing study was not explained.
How to fix it: Work through prolonged APTT cases and state what correction or non-correction on mixing means.
Point-of-care ultrasound
What went wrong: Lung ultrasound B-lines were confused with chest X-ray Kerley B lines and M-mode was misread.
How to fix it: Revise defining features of lung ultrasound artefacts and practise with saved clips.
Knowing college documents
What went wrong: Candidates were unfamiliar with CICM professional documents such as the one on patient transport.
How to fix it: Read the CICM IC-series documents relevant to transport, staffing and minimum standards.
Advice for the next sitting
Justify each step; unexplained lists score poorly.
Read the stem twice for patient-specific details that change management.
Use the CICM glossary to match depth to the instruction word.
Know CICM professional documents, which are examinable.
Original questions written to train the themes above (not questions from the exam). Answer each to see the explanation and why the other options are wrong.
Question 1 of 5Odds versus risk
In a cohort of 50 patients receiving a drug, 10 develop delirium. What are the odds of delirium in this group?
Pick an answer to see the explanation.
Fix what the examiners said
The same habits cost marks sitting after sitting. Each one has a short drill of questions from the Intensive care bank that test exactly that habit.