CICM First Part Examination (MCQ, SAQ, vivas) 2024.2 (August/October 2024): what the examiners said
Report released October 2024 · Summary checked
The headline
Candidates listed facts without explaining or applying them to intensive care, so structure, depth and breadth were the main gaps.
An independent plain-English summary. Fellowship Ready is not affiliated with or endorsed by the CICM. Read the original report on the CICM website. Read the full report.
Results and format
Results: 100 sat the written; 48 passed. MCQ pass 97%. 49 were invited to the vivas; the report records 49 as passing overall.
Format: Two 2.5-hour written papers, each with 50 MCQs and 10 SAQs; candidates passing both MCQ and SAQ components proceed to eight 10-minute cross-table vivas.
What candidates did well
MCQs were well done.
Ultrasound physics was the best-performed SAQ.
Antidote mechanisms and platelet function were relatively well answered.
Where marks were lost, and how to fix it
Cardiovascular drug pharmacodynamics
What went wrong: The contrasting effects of metoprolol and verapamil on action potentials, heart rate and vascular resistance were poorly detailed.
How to fix it: Compare beta-blockers and calcium channel blockers by ion channel, tissue and haemodynamic effect.
Carbon dioxide physiology
What went wrong: Carriage of CO2 (Haldane effect), dead space and chemoreceptor control were missed.
How to fix it: Map every determinant of PaCO2: production, carriage, ventilation and dead space.
Renal acid handling
What went wrong: Ammonium excretion and titratable acidity across the nephron were incomplete.
How to fix it: Draw each nephron segment's role in acid excretion and bicarbonate regeneration.
Procedural anatomy
What went wrong: Tissue layers and the neurovascular bundle for intercostal catheter insertion were weakly described.
How to fix it: Learn the safe triangle and intercostal anatomy and relate them to complications.
Metabolic physiology
What went wrong: Lactate production, the Cori cycle and renal handling were weak.
How to fix it: Trace lactate from production to clearance and its role as a fuel.
Oxygen as a drug
What went wrong: The pharmacology of oxygen, especially toxicity and kinetics, was incompletely covered.
How to fix it: Treat oxygen like any drug: presentation, dose, kinetics, effects, toxicity.
Advice for the next sitting
Use point form and attempt every question.
Apply facts to ICU contexts rather than reciting them.
Original questions written to train the themes above (not questions from the exam). Answer each to see the explanation and why the other options are wrong.
Question 1 of 5Cardiovascular drug pharmacodynamics
Compared with metoprolol, which effect is more prominent with IV verapamil?
Pick an answer to see the explanation.
Fix what the examiners said
The same habits cost marks sitting after sitting. Each one has a short drill of questions from the Intensive care bank that test exactly that habit.