CICM examiner reports · 2023.2 (August/October 2023) CICM First Part Examination (MCQ, SAQ, vivas) 2023.2 (August/October 2023): what the examiners said Report released October 2023 · Summary checked 18 November 2026
The headline
Less than half passed the written, with very low pass rates on questions that needed explanation of mechanisms rather than recall.
An independent plain-English summary. Fellowship Ready is not affiliated with or endorsed by the CICM. Read the original report on the CICM website. Read the full report .
Results What went wrong Advice Practice questions Results and format Results: 106 sat the written; 42 scored over 50% and 45 were invited to the vivas. MCQ pass 92%. 43 passed overall.
Format: Two 2.5-hour written papers, each with 50 MCQs and 10 SAQs; candidates passing both MCQ and SAQ components proceed to eight 10-minute cross-table vivas.
What candidates did well MCQ performance was good. Adrenoceptors and energy stores in starvation were relatively well answered. Sedation and hypothermia effects were reasonably known. Where marks were lost, and how to fix it Fluid chemistry What went wrong: Differences between Hartmann's and 0.9% saline in chemistry and acid-base effects were poorly explained.
How to fix it: Learn the strong ion difference of common fluids and predict their acid-base effect.
Monitoring errors What went wrong: Sources of error in pulse oximetry were not detailed.
How to fix it: List intrinsic and extrinsic error sources for each monitor and the direction of error.
Gas transfer physiology What went wrong: Diffusion- and perfusion-limited gas transfer was poorly explained.
How to fix it: Use carbon monoxide, nitrous oxide and oxygen examples to explain each pattern.
Chronic cardiac adaptation What went wrong: Chronic left ventricular responses to sustained afterload, such as hypertrophy, were missed.
How to fix it: Separate acute and chronic responses in every cardiovascular answer.
Immunology What went wrong: The complement system's pathways and regulation were poorly known.
How to fix it: Draw the three activation pathways converging on C3 and the regulators.
Advice for the next sitting Attempt every question and allocate time evenly. Explain how and why, not just what. Write legibly and use structured headings. Read beyond the recommended texts for depth. Read the full report: CICM First Part Examination Report 2023.2 ↗
Practise the weak spots: 5 questions Original questions written to train the themes above (not questions from the exam). Answer each to see the explanation and why the other options are wrong.
Question 1 of 5 Fluid chemistry
Why does large-volume 0.9% sodium chloride cause a metabolic acidosis? A It contains lactate that is metabolised to acid B It is hypotonic, causing dilution of bicarbonate only C Its strong ion difference is zero D It contains free hydrogen ions
Pick an answer to see the explanation. Next question →
Question 1 of 5 · Fluid chemistry
Why does large-volume 0.9% sodium chloride cause a metabolic acidosis?
It contains lactate that is metabolised to acid It is hypotonic, causing dilution of bicarbonate only Its strong ion difference is zero It contains free hydrogen ions Show the answer C. Its strong ion difference is zero
Saline has equal sodium and chloride, so its SID is zero. Infusing it lowers plasma SID (about 40) and causes a hyperchloraemic acidosis. Hartmann's solution has an effective SID of about 28 because lactate is metabolised. References: CICM First Part syllabus (acid-base, fluids); Australian Injectable Drugs Handbook (compound sodium lactate); SPLIT and PLUS trials (ANZICS Clinical Trials Group).
Why not A: Saline contains no lactate; Hartmann's lactate is metabolised to bicarbonate. Why not B: Saline is roughly isotonic; the issue is chloride, not tonicity. Why not D: Saline has a pH near 5.5 but negligible buffering acid content. Question 2 of 5 · Drug interactions and toxicity
A patient on IV aminophylline starts ciprofloxacin. What is the expected interaction?
Lower theophylline levels from enzyme induction Higher theophylline levels No interaction Higher ciprofloxacin levels Show the answer B. Higher theophylline levels
Theophylline is metabolised by CYP1A2. Ciprofloxacin and erythromycin inhibit it, raising levels and risking arrhythmias and seizures. Smoking induces CYP1A2 and lowers levels. References: Australian Medicines Handbook (theophylline); Australian Injectable Drugs Handbook (aminophylline).
Why not A: Ciprofloxacin is an enzyme inhibitor, not an inducer. Why not C: There is a clinically important interaction. Why not D: Theophylline does not raise ciprofloxacin levels. Question 3 of 5 · Monitoring errors
A patient rescued from a house fire has an SpO2 of 99% on a standard pulse oximeter. What is the main limitation?
Carboxyhaemoglobin falsely raises the reading Methaemoglobin causes the reading to fall to 85% Smoke causes motion artefact Cyanide makes the probe overheat Show the answer A. Carboxyhaemoglobin falsely raises the reading
Carboxyhaemoglobin absorbs light at 660 nm much like oxyhaemoglobin, so two-wavelength oximeters overestimate true saturation. Co-oximetry on a blood gas is required. References: ANZCA PG18 monitoring standards; CICM First Part syllabus (measurement).
Why not B: Methaemoglobin drives readings towards 85%, but that is not the issue in smoke inhalation. Why not C: Smoke does not cause motion artefact. Why not D: Cyanide does not affect probe temperature. Question 4 of 5 · Gas transfer physiology
Which gas is the classic example of diffusion-limited transfer across the alveolar membrane?
Nitrous oxide Nitrogen Carbon dioxide at rest Carbon monoxide Show the answer D. Carbon monoxide
Carbon monoxide binds haemoglobin so avidly that its partial pressure in capillary blood barely rises, so uptake is limited by diffusion across the membrane. That is why it is used to measure diffusing capacity. Nitrous oxide equilibrates quickly and is perfusion-limited. References: CICM First Part syllabus (respiratory physiology); West's Respiratory Physiology.
Why not A: Nitrous oxide is perfusion-limited. Why not B: Nitrogen is not a model gas for diffusion limitation. Why not C: CO2 normally equilibrates quickly and is not diffusion-limited at rest. Question 5 of 5 · Chronic cardiac adaptation
What is the chronic left ventricular adaptation to sustained pressure overload such as aortic stenosis?
Eccentric hypertrophy Ventricular dilation with thin walls Concentric hypertrophy No structural change Show the answer C. Concentric hypertrophy
Pressure overload raises wall stress (Laplace's law), prompting sarcomeres to be added in parallel and walls to thicken. This lowers wall stress but causes diastolic dysfunction and higher oxygen demand. Volume overload produces eccentric hypertrophy. References: CICM First Part syllabus (cardiovascular physiology); Guyton and Hall Textbook of Medical Physiology.
Why not A: Eccentric hypertrophy follows volume overload. Why not B: Dilation with thin walls is late decompensation or volume overload. Why not D: Sustained pressure overload always remodels the ventricle. Create a free account to keep going →
Fix what the examiners said The same habits cost marks sitting after sitting. Each one has a short drill of questions from the Intensive care bank that test exactly that habit.
Practise the rest free. CICM-style questions on every area the examiners keep flagging, each marked with a reason for every option. Free account, no card.
Other CICM sittings 2026.1 (March/May 2026) · released June 2026
Second Part Examination (written SAQs, hot cases, vivas) 2026.1 (March/May 2026): what the examiners said
Generic, template answers that ignored the specific patient and the exact instruction word were the main reason marks were lost.
2026.1 (February/April 2026) · released May 2026
First Part Examination (MCQ, SAQ, vivas) 2026.1 (February/April 2026): what the examiners said
The exam now rewards physiology and pharmacology applied to intensive care; answers that ignored the ICU and intravenous context lost marks.
2025.2 (August/October 2025) · released November 2025
Second Part Examination (written SAQs, hot cases, vivas) 2025.2 (August/October 2025): what the examiners said
Candidates who answered exactly what was asked, for the patient in front of them, with a reason for each decision, passed; ABCD templates did not.
All CICM examiner reports →
Source
CICM First Part Examination Report 2023.2 (CICM, October 2023)
An independent plain-English summary. Fellowship Ready is not affiliated with or endorsed by the CICM. Read the original report on the CICM website. Summaries are in our own words; formats and pass rules change, so always check the college's current information. Not affiliated with the CICM.