CICM Hot Case Technique: How to Pass the Second Part Hot Cases
Hot cases are the hardest part of the CICM Second Part. In the 2026.1 examination report, only 40% of candidates passed both. Each hot case gives you 2 minutes of preparation, then a 20-minute encounter in which you examine an ICU patient with an acute problem and discuss the case with the examiners. Confirm current details on the CICM website.
What examiners say goes wrong
The 2026.1 report lists the recurring problems: missing or misreading key signs, describing signs that are not present, an unfocused or incomplete examination, rough technique that causes discomfort, poor synthesis, a narrow differential, weak interpretation of data and imaging, hesitant management that needs heavy prompting, and running out of time. The overall question is whether the candidate could safely take charge of the unit.
Use the 2 minutes
- Read the task line closely. What are you asked to do: examine a system, assess readiness to wean, explain a deterioration?
- Note the key facts: age, day of admission, diagnosis, current support.
- Plan your examination order around the task, not a full routine.
- Think of the two or three things you most expect to find, and the one you must not miss.
Examine the ICU patient, not just the body
Start at the end of the bed and work in from the room: ventilator settings and waveforms, infusions with their rates and doses, monitor values, drains and their contents, lines and their sites, and the bedside chart if allowed. Then examine the patient, focused on the task. Be gentle and introduce yourself, even to a sedated patient.
Present a synthesis, not a list
When you present, open with a one-sentence summary that answers the task. For example: "This patient has persistent hypoxaemic respiratory failure on day 6 with a new right-sided effusion, and is not ready to wean." Then give the key positive and negative findings that support it, a short differential, and what you would do next.
Commit to management
Hesitancy and needing heavy prompting are marked down. When the examiners ask what you would do, say it plainly with a dose, a target or a test, and why. If you are uncertain, give your working plan and what would change it. That is how a consultant talks.
Practise the right way
- Practise on patients you do not know, at least weekly, with a consultant examining.
- Time every case. Stop at 20 minutes, even mid-sentence, and review what got cut.
- Practise presenting your synthesis in one sentence.
- Rotate systems: respiratory, cardiovascular, neurological, abdominal, and the whole patient for weaning or readiness questions.
The cross-table vivas
There are eight vivas, each with 2 minutes of reading and 10 minutes with the examiners. The 2026.1 report notes knowledge gaps, poorly structured answers, inability to justify reasoning, and reliance on generic statements. Structure each answer, link it to the case, and give your reason for every decision.
The radiology viva had a 59% pass rate in 2026.1. The examiners noted that candidates rushed, did not scroll through every slice, were not systematic, spent too long on lines and hardware, and did not link findings to the clinical question. Stronger candidates described findings anatomically using radiological terms and explained what they meant clinically. That skill is built by scrolling many real scans.
Managing nerves
The examiners note that nerves affect some candidates, and hot cases are where it shows most. The best defence is familiarity: enough timed practice on unknown patients that the routine runs by itself. On the day, use the 2 minutes to slow down. If you lose your place during the examination, go back to your system order and carry on. If you are unsure of a sign, examine it again carefully rather than guessing. A calm, methodical candidate who commits to a plan reads as someone who can run the unit.
Fellowship Ready has hot cases and vivas on the real clock with feedback on your spoken answer. You can start free, no card needed, and practise scrolling CT on the free Anatomy Scroller at fellowshipready.com.au/icu/anatomy.
Try 20 free questions.
CICM-style questions, marked with a reason for every option. Free account, no card.
Free, no sign-up: scroll a real CT, head to pelvis →
Next: How to Pass the CICM First and Second Part Exams: A Game Plan →
Next: CICM SAQ Technique: How to Write 10-Minute Answers That Score →
Next: CICM SAQ Example: Raised ICP in Traumatic Brain Injury →
Not affiliated with the CICM.