CICM SAQ Example: Raised ICP in Traumatic Brain Injury
This is an original practice question in the style of the CICM Second Part SAQ, not a recalled exam question. Severe traumatic brain injury tests tiered management, physiological targets and the evidence base, which makes it a good model for how CICM answers should be structured. Give yourself 10 minutes and write in full before comparing.
The stem
A 28-year-old man was admitted 18 hours ago after a motorbike crash with a severe traumatic brain injury. His initial GCS was 6. CT showed diffuse injury with small contusions and no surgical lesion. An intraparenchymal ICP monitor was placed. He is sedated with propofol and fentanyl, ventilated, and on noradrenaline. His ICP has risen to 28 mmHg over the last hour, with MAP 80 mmHg, temperature 38.4 °C, sodium 138 mmol/L and PaCO2 42 mmHg.
Part A. Outline your management of his raised intracranial pressure. (7 marks)
Check first. Treat sustained ICP above about 22 mmHg. Confirm the reading is real (monitor and waveform), look for a cause (CT to exclude a new surgical lesion), and check basics.
- General measures: head up about 30 degrees, neck neutral, tube ties not obstructing venous drainage; adequate sedation and analgesia; treat fever towards normothermia; normoglycaemia; seizure screening (consider EEG) and seizure prophylaxis for the first 7 days.
- Ventilation: SpO2 and PaO2 in the normal range; PaCO2 to the low-normal range, around 35–38 mmHg (his 42 is too high).
- Perfusion: CPP target of about 60–70 mmHg; his current CPP is about 52 mmHg (80 minus 28), so raise MAP with noradrenaline while treating ICP.
- Tier 1: hyperosmolar therapy, either mannitol (for example 0.5–1 g/kg) or hypertonic saline, with sodium and osmolality monitoring. Consider an external ventricular drain for CSF drainage if feasible.
- Tier 2: mild hyperventilation to PaCO2 32–35 mmHg with brain oxygenation monitoring if available; a trial of neuromuscular blockade; higher-dose sedation.
- Tier 3: barbiturate coma (with EEG and haemodynamic support), or decompressive craniectomy after neurosurgical discussion.
- Avoid: corticosteroids, which increased mortality in CRASH; prophylactic hypothermia, which did not improve outcome in POLAR.
Part B. Evaluate the evidence for decompressive craniectomy in this setting. (3 marks)
- DECRA (early bifrontotemporal craniectomy for diffuse injury with moderately raised ICP): lowered ICP and ICU days, but more patients had an unfavourable functional outcome at 6 months.
- RESCUEicp (craniectomy as a last-tier option for refractory ICP above 25 mmHg): lower mortality, but more survivors in a vegetative state or with severe disability.
- Interpretation: craniectomy trades mortality for more survivors with disability. It is reasonable as a last-tier option for refractory ICP, not as an early routine step, and the decision should involve the family and an understanding of what outcome the patient would accept.
Where the marks live
- A tiered structure makes it easy for the marker to find each point and shows you escalate logically.
- Numbers: ICP threshold, CPP target, PaCO2 target, sodium monitoring.
- Using the stem: the fever, the high PaCO2 and the low CPP are each fixable and each a point.
- Evidence named correctly: DECRA and RESCUEicp answer different questions. Mixing them up costs marks.
- Values and outcomes: an evaluation question rewards a balanced judgement, not a list of trial names.
Check current guidance such as the Brain Trauma Foundation and SIBICC consensus when you revise, as thresholds and tier contents are updated.
How to practise this
Common wrong answers
- Going straight to mannitol without checking the basics: positioning, sedation, fever and PaCO2.
- Ignoring CPP, or treating ICP while the MAP stays too low.
- Routine aggressive hyperventilation, which risks cerebral ischaemia.
- Recommending steroids or prophylactic hypothermia.
- Describing DECRA and RESCUEicp as if they showed the same thing.
Notice also what the model answer does not contain: a long account of the Monro-Kellie doctrine or a history of ICP monitoring. Background physiology is only worth writing if the question asks for it. In a 10-minute management question, every line should be an action, a target or a reason.
Write answers like this under a 10-minute clock and mark them against a model. Fellowship Ready has original First and Second Part SAQs marked point by point, plus vivas and hot cases on the CICM clock. You can start free, no card needed.
Try 20 free questions.
CICM-style questions, marked with a reason for every option. Free account, no card.
Free, no sign-up: scroll a real CT, head to pelvis →
Next: How to Pass the CICM First and Second Part Exams: A Game Plan →
Next: CICM SAQ Technique: How to Write 10-Minute Answers That Score →
Next: CICM Hot Case Technique: How to Pass the Second Part Hot Cases →
Not affiliated with the CICM.