CICM SAQ Technique: How to Write 10-Minute Answers That Score
The CICM Second Part written section is 30 SAQs over two papers, about 10 minutes each. The examiners' reports return to the same problems again and again: generic proforma answers, missed parts of multi-part questions, time spent on the wrong sections, and findings listed without interpretation. Each of these is a technique problem, and each can be fixed with practice.
Tailor every answer to the patient
The most common criticism is an answer that would fit any patient with the same diagnosis: ABC, lines, cultures, antibiotics. If the stem says day 2 after surgery, those were done two days ago. Ask yourself what is different about this patient, at this point in the illness, and write that.
Give a dose, a target and a reason
- A management choice without a dose or target is half a point at best.
- Add the reason in a few words: the physiology, the trial, or the guideline.
- Name the evidence where it matters, and state it accurately. A trial named wrongly costs credibility.
Pace by marks
Multi-part questions show the marks for each part. Spend time in proportion. The examiners specifically criticise pages on a small section and a single line on a large one. Write a stop time for each question and keep to it.
Interpret, do not list
When a question gives data such as a blood gas, a ventilator trace, a chest X-ray description or haemodynamics, the marks are for saying what it means for this patient. "Lactate 4.8" is a restatement. "Rising lactate despite vasopressor escalation suggests inadequate source control or ongoing hypoperfusion" is an interpretation.
A worked mini-example
This is an original practice item, not a recalled question. A 45-year-old man (predicted body weight 70 kg) has severe pneumonia with ARDS. On volume control, tidal volume 600 mL, PEEP 8, FiO2 0.8, his PaO2 is 56 mmHg (P/F ratio 70) and plateau pressure is 34 cmH2O. Outline your ventilation strategy. (10 marks)
A weak answer: "Lung-protective ventilation, increase PEEP, consider prone positioning and ECMO." The right ideas, but no numbers and no reasons.
A strong answer:
- Reduce tidal volume to 6 mL/kg predicted body weight (420 mL); his current 600 mL is about 8.6 mL/kg.
- Keep plateau pressure at or below 30 cmH2O and aim for a driving pressure of 15 cmH2O or less.
- Increase PEEP using a PEEP/FiO2 table or a titration method, watching plateau pressure, compliance and haemodynamics.
- Accept permissive hypercapnia, as long as pH stays above about 7.2 and there is no contraindication such as raised intracranial pressure.
- Prone positioning for at least 16 hours a day, as his P/F ratio is below 150 (PROSEVA).
- Ensure deep sedation and ventilator synchrony; consider a short course of neuromuscular blockade for refractory dyssynchrony, noting that routine early paralysis did not improve mortality in ROSE.
- Conservative fluid strategy once shock has resolved.
- Early discussion with an ECMO centre if severe hypoxaemia or hypercapnic acidosis persists despite optimised ventilation and proning (EOLIA criteria).
Each point has a number, a threshold or a named trial, and the answer uses the stem: it converts tidal volume to this patient's weight and uses his P/F ratio to justify proning. Check details against current guidelines when you practise; the aim here is the shape of the answer.
Common SAQ types
- Management of a specific patient at a specific moment.
- Data interpretation: blood gases, ventilator waveforms, haemodynamic data, imaging descriptions.
- Critical evaluation of a therapy or trial: the evidence for and against, then your view.
- Ethics and communication: capacity, end-of-life decisions, organ donation, family conflict.
Critical evaluation questions
Questions that ask you to evaluate or critically appraise a therapy need a different structure from management questions. Give the rationale for the therapy, the key evidence for and against with trial names stated accurately, the limitations of that evidence, and then your own conclusion and how you would use the therapy in practice. Examiners want a judgement at the end, not just a list of trials. Keep it brief: in 10 minutes, three trials described well beat eight named without comment.
Fellowship Ready marks your SAQ answers point by point, so you can see which line would have scored. You can start free, no card needed.
Try 20 free questions.
CICM-style questions, marked with a reason for every option. Free account, no card.
Free, no sign-up: scroll a real CT, head to pelvis →
Next: How to Pass the CICM First and Second Part Exams: A Game Plan →
Next: CICM Hot Case Technique: How to Pass the Second Part Hot Cases →
Next: CICM SAQ Example: Raised ICP in Traumatic Brain Injury →
Not affiliated with the CICM.