RACS Fellowship Example Question: Acute Cholangitis
This is an original practice question written in the style of a General Surgery Fellowship Exam short answer question. It is not a recalled exam question. Give yourself 15 minutes, write your answer in full, and only then read the model answer.
The question
A 78-year-old woman presents to the emergency department with two days of right upper quadrant pain, rigors and jaundice. She is confused. Her temperature is 39.2°C, heart rate 124, blood pressure 84/50 mmHg after 1 litre of crystalloid. Bilirubin is 96 µmol/L, white cell count 22 × 10⁹/L, creatinine 190 µmol/L (baseline normal) and platelets 85 × 10⁹/L. Ultrasound shows gallstones and a common bile duct of 11 mm. She takes apixaban for atrial fibrillation.
Part A: What is the diagnosis and how severe is it? Part B: Outline your management over the first 24 hours. Part C: How will you manage her gallbladder?
Model answer: Part A
- Acute cholangitis secondary to choledocholithiasis, with septic shock.
- Severe (Tokyo grade III): she has organ dysfunction in more than one system, including hypotension needing support, confusion, acute kidney injury and thrombocytopenia.
- Grading matters because it sets the urgency of biliary drainage.
Model answer: Part B
- Resuscitation now: two large-bore cannulae, further fluid boluses guided by response, early vasopressor support via central access if she remains hypotensive, oxygen, urinary catheter and hourly urine output.
- Escalation: refer to intensive care early for vasopressors and close monitoring.
- Investigations: blood cultures before antibiotics (without delaying them), lactate, coagulation, liver function, lipase, group and screen.
- Antibiotics within the hour: broad-spectrum intravenous therapy for biliary sepsis according to Therapeutic Guidelines and local resistance patterns, adjusting doses for her renal function.
- Anticoagulation: withhold apixaban; note the time of the last dose; plan with the endoscopist and haematology advice on whether reversal is needed before the procedure.
- Source control: urgent biliary drainage once she is being resuscitated, not after she has 'stabilised' for a day. ERCP with sphincterotomy or stent placement is first line; in a coagulopathic, unstable patient a simple biliary stent without sphincterotomy is a reasonable compromise.
- Bail-out: if ERCP fails or is not available, percutaneous transhepatic biliary drainage. Open common bile duct exploration is a last resort in this setting.
- Communication: explain the seriousness to the patient and family, discuss goals of care given her age and comorbidity, and document.
Model answer: Part C
- Once she has recovered, she should be offered cholecystectomy to prevent recurrent biliary events, ideally during the same admission or soon after, if her fitness allows.
- Assess her fitness formally: cardiac status, frailty, and the views of the patient and family.
- If she is not fit for surgery, a long-term biliary stent or sphincterotomy alone is an accepted alternative, accepting a risk of recurrent gallbladder problems.
- If cholecystectomy is difficult on the day, know the bail-out: subtotal cholecystectomy rather than unsafe dissection in the hepatocystic triangle.
Where the marks are
- Naming the severity. Many candidates write 'cholangitis' and stop. The grade earns a mark and drives the rest of the answer.
- Antibiotics early and resuscitation running at the same time as planning drainage. Answers that wait for imaging or for stability lose the point about urgency.
- The anticoagulant. It is in the stem for a reason. Missing it is the most common single loss on a question like this.
- A bail-out for failed ERCP. Percutaneous drainage shows you have thought about what happens when plan A fails.
- Part C as a decision, not a lecture. Cholecystectomy if fit, stent if not, with the reasons.
What a weak answer looks like
'Resuscitate, give antibiotics, ERCP, then cholecystectomy later' is not wrong. It would probably fail. It does not state severity, give the timing of drainage, deal with the apixaban, offer an alternative when ERCP fails, or show any judgement about whether a frail 78-year-old should have her gallbladder out. The Fellowship Exam rewards the reasoning that turns a correct list into a safe plan.
Turning one question into ten
Use this stem to practise variations. Make her 35 and pregnant. Make the CT show a pancreatic head mass instead of stones. Remove the hypotension so she becomes grade I. Each version changes the decision, and practising that change is how you learn the reasoning instead of memorising one answer.
Fellowship Ready has a bank of original short answer questions and spot questions like this one, marked point by point against what examiners look for. You can start free, no card needed.
Try 20 free questions.
RACS-style questions, marked with a reason for every option. Free account, no card.
Free, no sign-up: scroll a real CT, head to pelvis →
Next: How to Pass the RACS General Surgery Fellowship Exam →
Next: RACS Fellowship Paper 2: Short Answer Question Technique →
Next: RACS Fellowship Vivas and Short Cases: How to Perform →
Not affiliated with the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons.