RACS Fellowship Paper 2: Short Answer Question Technique
Paper 2 of the General Surgery Fellowship Exam is a set of short answer questions, each with about 15 minutes and each marked pass or fail. You do not collect partial credit across the paper the way you might in an MCQ. Each answer has to convince the marker, on its own, that you would manage this problem safely as a new consultant.
That changes how you should write. The goal is not to show everything you know. It is to answer the exact question in a structure the marker can follow, with the decisions stated.
Why good surgeons fail short answers
- They answer a neighbouring question: the workup when asked for immediate management, or the operative steps when asked for the indications.
- They write an unstructured list, so the marker cannot see priorities.
- They describe a process and hand every decision to someone else: 'discuss with radiology', 'consider ICU'.
- They spend 25 minutes on a question they love and leave the last one blank. A blank is a fail.
A structure that works for most clinical questions
- Restate the working diagnosis or problem in one line, including severity if the stem gives it to you.
- Immediate safety and resuscitation: airway, access, fluids or blood, analgesia, antibiotics if sepsis is likely. Be specific.
- Targeted investigations, each with the reason or the decision it informs.
- The decision: what you will do, and what finding changes that. 'Viable limb: anticoagulate and image. Immediately threatened: theatre now.'
- Definitive treatment, including the bail-out if things go wrong.
- After the event: complications to watch for, secondary prevention, follow-up, and communication with the patient and family.
Not every question needs every heading. Read the verb. 'Outline the principles' wants a framework. 'Describe your immediate management' wants the first hour. 'What are the indications' wants a list of indications and nothing else.
Be specific enough to score
'Give antibiotics' and 'give intravenous antibiotics according to local guidelines, for example covering gram-negative and anaerobic organisms for an intra-abdominal source' are different answers. So are 'image the patient' and 'CT angiography, provided it does not delay revascularisation'. Name the drug class, the dose where it matters, the imaging test, the operation and the threshold. Specific answers look like a consultant wrote them.
Worked mini-example
Original practice question (15 minutes): A 74-year-old man with atrial fibrillation, not anticoagulated, presents four hours after sudden onset of pain in the right leg. The leg is cold and pale below the knee. He has reduced sensation over the foot and mild weakness of toe dorsiflexion. No pulses are palpable below the femoral. Outline your management.
A pass-level answer, in note form:
- Working diagnosis: acute embolic limb ischaemia of the right leg, likely from atrial fibrillation, with sensory loss and mild motor deficit, so an immediately threatened limb (Rutherford IIb).
- Immediate: analgesia, intravenous access, bloods including full blood count, electrolytes and renal function, coagulation, group and hold, creatine kinase; ECG; intravenous unfractionated heparin bolus then infusion unless contraindicated.
- Decision: an immediately threatened limb needs revascularisation now. I would take him to theatre without delaying for imaging that would not change the plan; on-table angiography is available if needed.
- Operation: femoral exposure and balloon embolectomy, completion angiography; bypass or endovascular adjuncts if there is underlying atherosclerotic disease.
- Reperfusion: low threshold for four-compartment fasciotomy given the duration and motor deficit; monitor for compartment syndrome, hyperkalaemia, acidosis and myoglobinuria.
- Source and prevention: echocardiography, ongoing anticoagulation for atrial fibrillation, assess for other emboli.
- If the limb is non-viable (profound deficit, fixed mottling): discuss primary amputation or palliation with the patient and family.
- Communicate the risk of limb loss and death openly, document consent and the plan.
Notice what this answer does. It names the grade because the grade drives the decision. It states the decision. It gives the bail-out at both ends: fasciotomy if reperfusion goes badly, amputation if the limb is beyond saving. It avoids a long paragraph on the pathophysiology of embolism that nobody asked for.
Timing across the paper
With about 15 minutes per question, write a stop time next to each one before you start. When you hit it, finish the sentence and move on. A short but safe answer to every question beats perfect answers to six and a blank for two. If you have time at the end, go back and add the missing complication or follow-up point.
How to practise
Write answers under a timer, then compare them point by point with a marking guide, and list what you missed. After ten or fifteen questions you will see your own pattern: no decision, no bail-out, or no specifics. Fix that pattern and your pass rate rises quickly.
Fellowship Ready has original Paper 2 style short answer questions marked against the points examiners look for, plus spot questions on a five-minute clock. You can start free, no card needed.
Try 20 free questions.
RACS-style questions, marked with a reason for every option. Free account, no card.
Free, no sign-up: scroll a real CT, head to pelvis →
Next: How to Pass the RACS General Surgery Fellowship Exam →
Next: RACS Fellowship Vivas and Short Cases: How to Perform →
Next: RACS Fellowship Example Question: Acute Cholangitis →
Not affiliated with the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons.