RACS Fellowship Vivas and Short Cases: How to Perform
Five of the seven segments in the General Surgery Fellowship Exam are spoken: three vivas and two clinicals. Many candidates who are excellent surgeons find them harder than the written papers. The knowledge is the same; the problem is getting it out of your mouth in the right order, at the right level, inside the time.
This guide covers the format as described in recent Notes to Candidates and the habits that score. Confirm the current format with RACS before you sit.
The five spoken segments
- Operative surgery viva (about 30 minutes): a longer structured operative scenario, then several short scenarios prompted by clinical images.
- Pathophysiology, critical care and clinical reasoning viva (about 40 minutes): two longer scenarios plus short mini-scenarios.
- Clinical imaging and applied anatomy viva (about 32 minutes): a series of images, each with its own marking point.
- Clinical 1, medium cases (about 30 minutes): two cases, delivered electronically.
- Clinical 2, short cases (about 40 minutes): five cases, also electronic.
Each segment is examined by a pair of examiners. The College describes the vivas as a collegial discussion: examiners are trying to find out what you know, not to trick you. If you are stuck, ask for clarification, and follow their prompts. A prompt usually means you are heading away from the marks.
Rule one: speak like the consultant
The commonest reason for failing a viva is deferring. 'I'd discuss it with my consultant' and 'I'd get a radiology opinion' tell the examiner nothing about your judgement. Instead, say what you would do and why: 'I'd book her for laparoscopy tonight. If the CT shows a contained collection I would drain it percutaneously instead.' You can still mention a multidisciplinary meeting where that genuinely is the standard of care, such as cancer staging, but make your own recommendation first.
Rule two: lead with the answer
Examiners have limited time and a list of marking points. Give the headline first, then support it. 'This is an incarcerated femoral hernia, and she needs an operation today' is a better opening than five sentences of history. If they want the detail they will ask, and you will have already banked the key point.
The operative viva: always have a bail-out
Operative scenarios are built around a decision point. Before you describe a single port, know where the scenario could go wrong and what you would do. Take a difficult laparoscopic cholecystectomy:
- State your aim: the critical view of safety before anything is clipped or divided.
- Describe how you would try to get there: fundus-first dissection, staying on the gallbladder, getting help.
- Name the bail-out when you cannot: subtotal cholecystectomy (fenestrating or reconstituting), or a drain and referral, rather than pushing on into the porta.
- Say how you would recognise and manage a bile duct injury if it happened: stop, get help, define the injury, involve a hepatobiliary surgeon, and disclose openly.
The same pattern works for a perforated diverticulitis (resection and anastomosis versus Hartmann's), a damage-control laparotomy, or an unexpected finding at hernia repair.
The critical care viva: physiology with a plan
Pathophysiology questions are rarely abstract. They ask you to explain why the patient in front of you is deteriorating and what you will do about it. Link each piece of physiology to an action: rising abdominal pressure reduces venous return and renal perfusion, so measure bladder pressure and decompress if there is abdominal compartment syndrome. Know your shock classes, massive transfusion principles, and the early management of sepsis well enough to say them without hesitating.
The imaging and applied anatomy viva
Each image carries a marking point, so the clock matters. Use a fixed opening: what the image is (modality, plane, phase), the abnormality, and what it means for management. If you are shown a CT, orient yourself out loud for a second, then commit. Anatomy is tested in context: the relationship of the superior mesenteric vessels to the pancreatic head, the course of the recurrent laryngeal nerve, the contents of the femoral canal.
Medium and short cases
Clinical cases are now delivered electronically, but the old principles stand. State findings, not intentions: 'there is a 3 cm smooth, non-tender swelling in the right anterior triangle that moves with swallowing' rather than 'I would examine the neck'. Include the key negatives. Then give your most likely diagnosis, a short differential if relevant, and the next step.
With five short cases in about 40 minutes, do not dwell. If you are stuck on one, give your best answer and move on. A rescued short case is worth the same as a perfect one.
How to practise
- Do mock vivas out loud, with a timer, two or three times a week in the final months.
- Rotate examiners so you get used to different styles.
- Record yourself occasionally. Most candidates are surprised by how long they take to reach the point.
- After each session, write down the questions you deferred or fumbled, and prepare a one-line answer for each.
Fellowship Ready runs operative, critical care and imaging vivas plus medium and short cases on a timer, with marking against the points examiners look for. You can start free, no card needed, and use the free Anatomy Scroller at fellowshipready.com.au/surgery/anatomy to sharpen CT anatomy for the imaging viva.
Try 20 free questions.
RACS-style questions, marked with a reason for every option. Free account, no card.
Free, no sign-up: scroll a real CT, head to pelvis →
Next: How to Pass the RACS General Surgery Fellowship Exam →
Next: RACS Fellowship Paper 2: Short Answer Question Technique →
Next: RACS Fellowship Example Question: Acute Cholangitis →
Not affiliated with the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons.