RANZCP Scholarly Project: How to Plan It So It Actually Gets Finished
Most Scholarly Projects that stall do not fail on the science. They stall on logistics: a proposal that sits unapproved, an ethics application that takes longer than anyone expected, a supervisor who moves on, a data set that turns out to be twice the size it looked. The College expects the project to be attempted and passed by 60 months of full-time equivalent (FTE) training, and it is assessed at the standard expected at the end of Stage 3 whenever you submit it. This guide is about getting from a vague idea to a submitted report without it drifting into your final year.
First, check whether you need to do one at all
The College has an exemption pathway. You may be eligible if, within the past 10 years, you completed a doctoral, research Masters or Honours thesis, were a major author of a peer-reviewed, English-language journal article relevant to psychiatry or mental health, or completed a project judged substantially comparable to the Scholarly Project. Projects done as part of an undergraduate medical degree generally do not count unless they were completed in a separate, research-specific year.
- Apply early. Exemption applications are assessed in rounds, results take around two months after a round closes, and there is a fee.
- You get one attempt at exemption. If the application is rejected, you must complete a Scholarly Project and cannot apply for exemption again. Put your strongest evidence forward the first time.
- Do not run both tracks at once. If you already have an approved proposal, you must withdraw it in writing before applying for exemption, and you cannot apply while a submitted project is awaiting its result.
- Look at what you are already doing. If you are close to publishing something relevant from a previous research job or a service audit, finishing that paper may be the quickest route.
Keep the question small
The most common planning error is choosing a project sized for a PhD. The report is 3,000 to 5,000 words, and projects outside that range are returned unmarked. That is room for one clear question answered well, not three questions answered loosely. The College accepts original empirical research (quantitative, qualitative or mixed), a systematic or critical literature review, a case series, a full-cycle quality assurance clinical audit, or an equivalent project approved by the Scholarly Project Subcommittee.
A question that is the right size for a registrar usually:
- Uses data that already exists or that you can collect within your normal work, such as referral patterns, prescribing, or a file audit.
- Has one primary outcome you can state in a sentence.
- Survives a change of rotation halfway through.
- Answers something your service genuinely wants to know, which makes data access and goodwill much easier to get.
Choose a supervisor for research experience, not convenience
Your principal supervisor must be a College-accredited supervising Fellow. A co-supervisor is optional and does not need to be a Fellow, and at least one of your supervisors should have relevant expertise and research interest. The most useful thing a supervisor brings is experience of actually finishing research: they know how long ethics takes at your health service, who extracts data, and what a realistic timeline looks like.
Questions worth asking a prospective supervisor:
- Have you supervised a Scholarly Project, or similar research, through to completion?
- Will you be at this service for the life of the project?
- How often can we meet, and how quickly can you turn a draft around?
- Is there an existing project or data set I could take an original question from?
That last option is legitimate. A project can sit within a larger study, but you must identify an original question and show your own contribution, and you must be the major author: a substantial contribution to the design, data collection, analysis and interpretation, and the writing. Two trainees can collaborate, but that intention has to be stated in the proposal.
Proposal and ethics: the slow part
Your Branch Training Committee (BTC) must approve your proposal before you start. It sets out the aim, the question or hypothesis, the methodology and your supervisor's details, on the form for your project type. Ethics approval does not have to be granted before you lodge the proposal, and the BTC can approve it conditionally while ethics is pending, but your final submission must include evidence of ethics approval or written advice that it is not required. Literature reviews do not need ethics approval. Case series do, along with valid patient consent.
Ethics and site governance approval is often the longest single wait in the whole project. Ask your supervisor or local research office how long applications typically take at your health service and plan from that, not from optimism. Quality assurance and low-risk pathways are often quicker than full review, but do not assume your project qualifies. If you later change the design substantially, you will need a revised proposal, so settle the method before you lodge anything.
A realistic timeline
Beyond the 60-month expectation the College does not set a timeline, so the safest approach is to work backwards from it. One sensible shape for a small project:
- Stage 1: choose a topic area and a supervisor, and check whether you are eligible for exemption.
- Early Stage 2: finalise the question, get BTC approval of the proposal, and lodge your ethics application.
- Mid Stage 2: collect data while approvals and access are fresh.
- Late Stage 2 or early Stage 3: analysis and write-up, with drafts going to your supervisor.
- A buffer: submit at least one round before you need to, so a conditional pass or a fail does not push you past 60 months.
Protect your write-up time
Trainees routinely underestimate the write-up. Even a short report needs a literature review that is critical rather than descriptive, methods described well enough to repeat, results that match the methods, and a discussion that owns its limitations. Then there are the formatting rules, including a cover page showing the word count, double spacing, Vancouver referencing, and de-identification of patients, locations and supervisors. Book protected time for it, and give your supervisor enough time to read drafts properly.
Read the College's assessment framework, which markers use, and look at the examples of successful projects the College publishes. Then check the current submission timetable and plan backwards from the cut-off you are aiming for. If you also hold or are planning a Certificate of Advanced Training, check whether one project can meet both requirements.
If it comes back conditional or failed
A conditional pass is only available on a first submission and gives you a short window to revise and resubmit, with no fee. A failed project goes to a second independent examiner. After a fail you can revise and resubmit or start again with a new proposal, and two fails require a targeted learning plan. All of this takes time, which is the best argument for submitting early.
If you want an independent read before you submit, Fellowship Ready offers an examiner-style written review of Scholarly Project drafts, marked against the College's assessment framework (details at /scholarly-project). And while the project runs in the background, keep your exam preparation moving: start free with 3 full MEQ cases and 20 MCQs, no card required.
Practise under real exam conditions
Sit timed MEQ cases and MCQ blocks with examiner-style marking. Start free with 3 MEQ cases and 20 MCQs, no card.
Start free →